$B!VK\=q$KEP>l$9$kJ]813X3X1!9bEy>&6H3XIt!J4X@>3X1!Bg3X>&3XIt$NA0?H!K$G3$>eJ]81$r9V$8$F$$$?GO^k8)@gBf;T$N@8$^$l!"El5~DkBgB4!K$G$"$k!#!W(B

$B!V%Y%9%H%;%i!<$dOCBj$N%O%&%D!<$b$N$r$I$s$I$sFI$_$5$(3P$($F$$$J$$FI=q$r$7$F$$$F$O!"?M@8$OK-$+$K$J$j$^$;$s!#B?$/$NK\$O;~$NN.$l$N$J$+$GK:$l$i$l!">C$(5n$C$F$$$-$^$9!#;E;v$N>e$GFI$^$J$1$l$P$J$i$J$$=qN`$,B?$$;~4|$K$O!"N.9T$NK\$rFI$s$G$$$k;~4V$O$"$^$j$"$j$^$;$s!#$=$NE@!"8EE5$O;~Be$,JQ$o$C$F$b@8$-;D$C$F$$$k$@$1$N2ACM$r$b$C$F$$$kK\$,B?$$$N$G!"FI$_JV$7$?$$0&FI=q$O:n$O2?G/$+$?$C$FFI$_JV$7$F$_$k$H!"<+J,$N7P83$K$h$C$FA0$KFI$s$@$H$-$K$O5$$,$D$+$J$+$C$?JL$N4i$r8+$;$F$/$l$^$9!#!W(B(p.113-114)

$B%[!<%`(B > $B $B!VGX?.!"E\$j!"NtEy46!D!W!!O"B3;&?MHH!&Lx1JE/$N@:?@@$3&(B

$B!!!V%8%-%kGn;N$H%O%$%I$OB?=E?M3J$G8_$$$NB8:_$rCN$i$J$$$,!";d$O;d$NF|>oE*$J;Q$H;&?M$rHH$9;~$N;Q$rA4$FCN$C$F$$$k!W(B $B!V;d$O$4$m$D$-$@!W!D!#(B

$B!!O"B3;&?MHH$NLx1JE/!J%f!&%h%s%A%g%k(B/35)$B$,<+?H$N@:?@4UDj$r9T$C$?%-%`!&%`%8%s(B(50)$B8x=#<#NE4F8n=jD9$KOC$7$?8@MU$@!#(B

$B!!@:?@2J@lLg0e$N%-%`=jD9$O:rG/(B11$B7n!"%=%&%k94CV=j$GLx1JE/$H(B7$B2s$K$o$?$jLLCL$7$?8e!"!VLx1JE/$OH?c32

$B!!%-%`=jD9$O(B10$BF|!"!VLx1JE/$O$F$s$+$s!"?'LU!"Ic?F$H7;$N<+;&$J$I$rOC$7$J$,$i!"<+?H$rHa7`$N-73(B($BI4:QKv4|$N>-73(B)$B$KSH$($k$J$I8XBgLQA[E*?4M}$b4Q;!$5$l$?!W$H8l$C$?!#(B

$B!!%-%`=jD9$O!"!VLx1JE/$NO"B3;&?M$O!"<~0O$KBP$9$kGX?.$dE\$j!"NtEy46$dIT6x$J2HDm4D6-$KBP$9$kH?46$J$I$NJ#9gE*$JI==P!W$H?GCG$7!"!VLx1JE/$ON%:'$7$FB);R$NM\0i8"$rC%$o$l!"F15o$7$F$$$?=w@-$bN%$l$F9T$-!"<~0O$KBP$9$kIT?.$,6K$^$C$?5s$26g!H:G8e$N4uK>$N9K!I$^$G

$B!!%-%`=jD9$O!VLx1JE/$K2q$C$F!"$^$C$H$&$J@-3J$NH/C#$H7A@.$K!"2HDm$NLr3d$,$I$l$[$I=EMW$G$"$k$+$r2~$a$F9M$($5$;$i$l$?!W$HOC$7$?!#(B

$BBgED!a%$%`!&%I%R%g%/5-

$B!V>k;3;0O:(B : $B!H>e5*;R(B, $B??;3?N(B, $B:49b?.(B, $BJ?>>2007$BG/(B8$B7n(B7$BF|(B($B2P(B)-28$BF|(B($B2P(B) $B2PMK(B22:25-22:50 NHK$B650i%F%l%S!XCN$k$r3Z$7$`(B. $B;d$N$3$@$o$j?MJ*EA!Y(B

WONG'S CHINOIS ($BO;K\LZ%R%k%:(B)

$B9qN)?7H~=Q4[(B

$B@ ($B$9$F$-$J$*$H$&$5$s(B ; 38)

[$B:#F|$N$$$-$b$N(B]$B62I]$N;`HVCn(B ($B%7%P%s%`%7(B) $B$"$N>.$5$JCn$N@5BN!X(B$B$$$-$b$NDL?.(B$B!Y(BVol. 278 (2005/8/7)

Editor's Eye $B!V(B$BOBK\$H$`$7(B$B!W!X5~8EK\$d1}Mh!Y!J(B$B5~ET8E=q8&5f2q(B$B!K(B81$B9f!!(B98$BG/(B7$B7n(B25$BF|H/9T(B

$BK\$NCn(B $B$"$l$3$l(B ($BC]@gF2(B/$BC]Q"F2(B)

$BOBEDFXI'!X%a%G%#%"$NCf$NFI$B=P8}0lM:!XFI=qO@$N7OIh!YEl5~(B : $B$f$^$K=qK<(B, 1994.2 ($B=q;o=qL\%7%j!<%:(B ; 35)

$B5*ED=g0lO:!XFI=q?M$N<~JU!YEl5~(B : $B$BKL:jG+><(B, $B:XF#John Boynton Priestley[$BCx(B] ; $BBg2OFb9/9T(B, $B5WEDC]0l(B($BJTCm$B@.H~F2(B, 1967.1

Priestley, J.B.(1945). An inspector calls. $B%W%j!<%9%H%j!<(B($B:n(B) ; $B0BF#DgM:(B($BLu(B)$B!X(B$BLk$NMhK,$B!YEl5~(B : $B4dGH=qE9(B, 2007.2 ($B4dGHJ88K(B ; $B@V(B(32)-294-1)

$B$J$s$+6H3&$0$k$_$G!V(BKY$B!aD+F|;98jYTB$!W$rKu>C$7$?$$$i$7$$(B 2007$BG/(B08$B7n(B12$BF|(B

$BD+F|?7J9$N!VD+F|;98j;v7o!W(B

$B4d0f;VKc;R(B$B!X9u$$D+!"Gr$$Lk!Y9VCL$B9b6651F$BEDCf[Y(B$B!X(B$B8EK\20$N=wK<(B$B!YEl5~(B : $BJ?K^$B2,:jIp;V!X8EK\20$5$s$NFf!YEl5~(B : $BF1J~$B>.ED8wM:(B, $B2OLn9b9'(B, $BEDB$BEbBt=S0l!X8EK\%^%K%";(3X%N!<%H!Y(B[1$B:}L\(B]$B!V?M@8$KBg@Z$J$3$H$O$9$Y$F8EK\20$G3X$s$@!WEl5~(B : $B%@%$%d%b%s%I$B=P5W:,C#O:!X$$$D$N$^$K$d$iK\$NCn!YEl5~(B : $B9VCL$B=P5W:,C#O:!X$$$D$N$^$K$d$iK\$NCn!YEl5~(B : $B9VCL$B9b6651$Bi>C_(B($B$&$s$A$/(B) : $BE9F$B>>B<5W(B($B;38}(B $B%^%D%N=qE9(B)$B!V!H$[$s!I$N9TJ}(B : $BCOJ}8EK\20$N4c!W(B. $B9b6651$Bi>C_(B($B$&$s$A$/(B) : $BE9F$BC+8}2mCK(B($BKL6e=#(B $B$U$k$[$sJ88K$d$5$s(B)$B!VJ88KK\@lLgE9$N$Bi>C_(B($B$&$s$A$/(B) : $BE9F$BC+8}2mCK!X(B$B$U$k$[$sJ88K$d$5$s$N4q@W(B$B!YEl5~(B : $B%@%$%d%b%s%I$BC+8}2mCK!X$U$k$[$sJ88K$d$5$s$N4q@W!YEl5~(B : $B?7D,$B?7D,(BOH!$BJ88K(B)

$B$o$?$7$,CN$i$J$$%9%4K\$O!"$-$C$H$"$J$?$,FI$s$G$$$k(B/Dain$B;a(B ($B%V%m%0(B | $B%M%C%HC5DeCD(B annex $B%$%s%?%S%e!<(B)

$B$o$?$7$,CN$i$J$$%9%4K\$O!"$-$C$H$"$J$?$,FI$s$G$$$k(B

• $BK\$rC5$9$N$G$O$J$/!"?M$rC5$9(B

  $B!V(B  $B$G$O!"Gc$&K\$HGc$o$J$$K\$r$I$&A*$V$+$K$D$$$F!"$o$?$7$N$d$jJ}$r>R2p$9$k!#(B

  $B%(%mK\$H<-=q0J30!"K\$OGc$o$J$$(B

  $B!!!VK\$OGc$o$J$$$H?H$K$D$+$J$$!W$H$+!VK\$NL\Mx$-$O?HA,$r@Z$C$F$3$=!W$H8@$o$l$k!#3N$+$K$=$NDL$j!#$o$?$7$N>l9g!"3+9b7r$K1F6A$5$l!"

  $B!!$7$+$7!"J'$C$?5>@7!J6b$H;~4V!K$,Bg$-$9$.$k!#;W$$=P$7$?$/$J$$$0$i$$$N$>$C$H$9$k3[$,$D$.9~$^$l$F$$$k!#F@$i$l$?!VL\!W$O$=$l$J$j$J$s$@$1$I!">.@b2H$dI>O@2H$G%a%76t$C$F$$$/$D$b$j$b$J$$!#$@$+$i!"!VA,$rJ'$&!WA0Ds$r$H$C$Q$i$C$F!"$b$C$HB>?M$NL\$rF~$l$l$PNI$+$C$?$H;W$C$F$$$k!#(B

  $B!!$5$i$K!"$3$N?HA,$r@Z$k$d$jJ}$@$H!"K\$N>DND$,J]$+$i$b;EF~$l$F$/$k$>!W$H$$$&H?O@$,Mh$=$&$@$,!"$I$N=qI>$r$I$&I>2A$9$k$+$N;~E@$G4{$K8GDj2=$7$F$$$k$3$H$K5$$E$$$F$$$J$$!#!W(B

  $B!V(B  $B7k6I$N$H$3$m!"$/$jJV$7;H$&K\$G$J$1$l$P!"K\$OGc$o$J$$$3$H$r;j>e$H$7$F$$$k!#Gc$&$3$H$KK~B-$7$F$7$^$C$F!"FI$^$J$$;vBV$rGS=|$9$k!#$o$,2H$O69$$!#<+8JK~B-%*%J%K!<$N$?$a$N%9%Z!<%9$J$s$FL5$$(B$B!#$I!<$7$F$bGc$&I,MW$,$"$k$b$N$@$1$rGc$$!";H$C$?$i!"B(Gd$k!#

  $B?^=q4[$rE0DlE*$K3hMQ$9$k(B

  $B!!$G$O!"$I$&$7$F$$$k$+$H$$$&$H"*?^=q4[$r;H$$E]$9!#:G6a$N?^=q4[$O$h$/$G$-$F$$$F!"%M%C%H8!:w$dM=Ls$,$+$1$i$l$k$b$N$,$"$k!#$=$l$rJ#?t;H$C$F

  $B!!(B$B!V?^=q4[$X9T$C$F$B!#Nc$($P!VEl5~ET$N?^=q4[2#CG8!:w!W(B[$B;29M(B]$B$rMxMQ$7$F!"<+J,$NFI$_$?$$K\$rB_$7=P$7$F$/$l$k?^=q4[$X=P$+$1$k!#!W(B

  $BK\$P$+$jFI$s$G$k$H%P%+$K$J$k(B

  $BLLGr$$>.@b$r8+$D$1$k(B3$B$D$NJ}K!(B

  $B>>2,@59d$NFI=q=Q(B

  $B;D9s$J0x2L$N%F!<%

  $B!V%m!<%^?M$NJ*8l!W$rNr;K$N@lLg2H$O$I$&I>2A$7$F$$$k$N$+!)(B

  $B!V%m!<%^?M$NJ*8l!W$NFI$_$I$3$m!Z$^$H$a![(B

$BLpLnE/:H(B

• $BFI=qK!(B(1) $BFI$`$Y$-K\$rCN$k(B
• $BFI=qK!(B(2) $BK\$NFI$_J}(B

  $B6b$N$J$$9b9;@8$K$H$C$F(B、$BGc$&K\$O7+$jJV$7FI$`$N$OE4B'$G$"$k(B。$B$D$^$j(B「$B0l@8FI$`(B！」$B$H3N?.$9$kK\$G$J$$8B$j(B、$BGc$&I,MW$O$J$$$@$m$&(B。

  「$B$A$g$C$HBT$F(B、$B26$O=q$-9~$_$r$7$?$$$s$@(B」$B$H$$$&?M$b$$$k$+$b$7$l$J$$(B。$B0lEY$7$+FI$^$J$$K\$r%^!<%-%s%0$7$FFI$_$?$$(B$B%D%o%b%N$J9b9;@8(B$B$J$s$F7y$$$@$,(B、$B%"%I%t%!%$%9$r$7$h$&(B。

  $B$^$:(B、$B%]%9%H%$%C%H$G$+$J$j$NItJ,BeMQ$G$-$k(B。$B.:Y9)$O$$$i$J$$(B。$B$=$&$$$&FI=q$,CN@-$H$7$FFs==$r2a$.$?$"$?$j$+$i0n$l$F$/$k$@$m$&(B。$B$=$&$J$j$c(B、$B$$$$=w$,$[$$$[$$$h$C$F$/$k$>(B。$BK\Ev$@(B。$B$=$7$FDK$$L\$r8+$F99$K7]=Q$K$O$^$j9~$`$3$H$@$m$&(B。$B$3$l$O(B$B40A4$JK!B'(B$B$G$"$k(B。

  $B$=$&$@(B。$B$3$s$J%V%m%0$rFI$`9b9;@8$J$s$F7y$$$@$,(B、$B9b9;@8$J$i;~4V$,$"$k$@$m$&(B。$B$J$s$J$i0lEY(B、$BK\$r0l:}(B、$BA4J8=q$-C<$J$3$H$r8@$&$N$J$i(B（$B$$$d(B、$B$=$s$J$3$HBg?M$K$J$C$F$+$i$G$$$$(B）、$B9b9;@8$J$i(B、$B$P$j$P$j(B、$B%a%b$r$H$C$F(B、$B46A[J8$r=q$$$F(B、$B5$$K$$$C$?K\$O0l:}$^$k$4$H%N!<%H$K$B$=$l$r2;FI$7$^$/$l(B。
  $B9{$l$3$s$@%U%l!<%:$O0E5-$7$m(B！
  $BAk$+$i6u$K8~$+$C$F6+$Y(B！ （$B$=$s$J9b9;@87y$$$@$,(B）

  $B$=$&$=$&(B。$B$*$l$O$d$i$J$+$C$?$,(B、$B=q$-H4$-%N!<%H$r:n$k$N$b$$$$$+$b$7$l$J$$(B。「$B=q$-H4$-(B」$B$J$s$F26$K$O>.:Y9)$K46$8$k$,(B、$B$^$"(B、$BBEEv$J:n6H$+$b$7$l$J$$(B。$B$3$l$O(B、$BK\$rFI$s$G$$$F5$$K$$$C$?J8$K0u$r$D$1$F$*$$$F(B、$B8e$G$=$l$r%N!<%H$K

  $BFI=qK!(B(3) 6$B$D$N$"$j$,$A$J4V0c$$(B

  $BFI=qK!(B(4) $BFI$`B.EY$r>e$2$k(B6$B$D$NJ}K!(B

  $BC/$G$b$G$-$kB.FIK!(B(1) $B$O$8$a$K(B

  $BC/$G$b$G$-$kB.FIK!(B(2) $B0lHLE*$JFI=q$NLdBjE@(B

  $BC/$G$b$G$-$kB.FIK!(B(3) $BF@$?$$>pJs$rL@3N$K$7$F!"L\

  $BC/$G$b$G$-$kB.FIK!(B(4) $B0lEY$KFI$_

  $BC/$G$b$G$-$kB.FIK!(B(5) $B0lEY$N@:FI$h$j$b?t2s$NH?I|(B - $B%^!<%/$N$9$9$a(B

  $B@~$r0z$-5-9f$r=q$-$J$i$,FI$`$3$H$G5-21$K$bDjCe$7$d$9$/]$=$N$b$N$rF,$KF~$l$k$h$&$K$7$FFI$`$H$h$$$G$7$g$&(B。
  
  $B0J>e$N$h$&$JFI$_J}$r$9$k$?$a$K$bK\$OGc$&$Y$-$G$9(B。$BK\$O2?EY$bFI$_=q9~$_$r$7(B、$B;~$K$OI,MW$J%Z!<%8$rGK$C$?$j$9$k$b$N$G$9(B。$B$b$A$m$sN)FI$_$G:Q$`$h$&$JK\$b@$$NCf$K$OBgNL$K$"$j$^$9(B。$B$7$+$7=EMW$JK\$OGc$o$J$/$F$O$$$1$^$;$s(B。
  
  *1：$BB.FI$H$$$&4QE@$+$i$9$k$HF@:v$G$O$J$$$N$G$9$,;d$OK\$K@~$r0z$-5-9f$r=q$$$F$$$^$9(B。$B@~$r0z$/$@$1$@$H2?$G0z$$$?$N$+K:$l$F$7$^$$$^$9$7(B、$B8e$+$iC5$9$H$-$K$b5-9f$,$"$C$?J}$,3Z$@$+$i$G$9(B。$B$^$?(B、$B%Z!<%8$O1x$7$?J}$,FbMF$O5-21$KDjCe$7$^$9(B。

  $B%7%s%W%k$KJk$i$9(B(1) $B%U%m!<$H%9%H%C%/$N6hJL$GIt20$NA]=|(B

  $B%7%s%W%k$KJk$i$9(B(2) $B$9$C$-$j%Q%=%3%sMxMQJ}K!(B

  $B%7%s%W%k$KJk$i$9(B(3) $B!V@0M}!W$N$?$a$N(B6$B$D$N%k!<%k(B

  $B%7%s%W%k$KJk$i$9(B(4) $BIt20$r9-$/8+$;$k(B8$B$D$N%3%D(B

  $B%7%s%W%k$KJk$i$9(B(5) 3$B$D$N(BC$B$rL5$/$7$F%9%H%l%9$+$i3+J|(B

  $B>pJs4IM}$NJ}K!(B(1) $BM}O@JS(B

$B!V>k;3;0O:(B : $B>NHK$B650i%F%l%S!X(BETV$BFC=8!Y(B

$BCf860I(B$B!X(B$B$-$i$j$s!y%l%\%j%e!<%7%g%s(B$B!Y(B(1). $B>.3X4[(B, 2004.10.5 ($B$A$c$*%3%_%C%/%9(B). 390$B1_!\>CHq@G(B5%. $BEl5^%9%H%"(B($B<+M3$,5VE9(B). 2007$BG/(B8$B7n(B15$BF|(B($B?e(B)

$BF#;R!&#F!&ITFsM:(B$B!X(B$B%I%i$($b$s(B$B!Y(B(1). $B>.3X4[(B, 1974.8.1 ($B$F$s$H$&Cn%3%_%C%/%9(B). 390$B1_!\>CHq@G(B5%. $BEl5^%9%H%"(B($B<+M3$,5VE9(B). 2007$BG/(B8$B7n(B15$BF|(B($B?e(B)

$B!X$-$i$j$s!y%l%\%j%e!<%7%g%s!YCf860I(B. (2). $B>.3X4[(B, 2005.3.5 ($B$A$c$*%3%_%C%/%9(B). 390$B1_!\>CHq@G(B5%. $BEl5^%9%H%"(B($B<+M3$,5VE9(B). 2007$BG/(B8$B7n(B16$BF|(B($BLZ(B)

$B!X%I%i$($b$s!YF#;R!&#F!&ITFsM:(B. (3). $B>.3X4[(B, 1974.10.1 ($B$F$s$H$&Cn%3%_%C%/%9(B). 390$B1_!\>CHq@G(B5%. $BEl5^%9%H%"(B($B<+M3$,5VE9(B). 2007$BG/(B8$B7n(B16$BF|(B($BLZ(B)

$B!X$"$C$A$3$C$A$?$^$4$C$A%?%&%s!Y$+$,$j=_;R(B. (1). $B>.3X4[(B, 2005.9.5 ($B$A$c$*%U%i%o!<%3%_%C%/%9%9%Z%7%c%k(B). 600$B1_!\>CHq@G(B5%. $BEl5^%9%H%"(B($B<+M3$,5VE9(B). 2007$BG/(B8$B7n(B16$BF|(B($BLZ(B)

[CD] Nina Hagen$B!X(BIrgendwo auf der Welt$B!Y(B2006

$BLnCf5,M:!V(B$B%K%J!&%O!<%2%s(B$B!W!J(B$B$B!K(B

Queen of Bitch$B!!(B[ Nina Hagen / Nun Sex Monk Rock ]

Rockstar Art Gallery

THE BEST OF TOYAH$B!?(BToyah

$B!V!X(BTHE BEST OF TOYAH$B!Y(B $B$O!"(B1998$BG/$KH/I=$5$l$?%H!<%d(B [ Toyah ] $B$N%Y%9%HHW$G$9!#!W(B

$B!VF|K\$G$O$"$^$jCNL>EY$N$J$$%H!<%d$G$9$,!"%@%K%(%k!&%@%C%/%9$d%j!<%J!&%i%t%#%C%A!"%K%J!&%O!<%2%s!"%5%C%U%)!/$7%$%a!<%8$,$:$l$^$9$,!"%9!<%8!

Lucky Number: The Best of Lene Lovitch

$B!V%j!<%J!&%i%t%#%C%A$O!"(B1949$BG/$K%G%H%m%$%H$G!"%$%.%j%9?M$NJl$H%;%k%S%"?M$NIc$N4V$G@8$^$l!"$=$N8e%$%.%j%9$K0\=;$7$^$7$?!#!W(B

$B!V%j!<%J$O(B82$BG/$K(B3rd$B%"%k%P%`!V(BNo Man's Land$B!WH/I=8e!"=P;:$H;R0i$F$N$?$a0l;~3hF0$rDd;_$7$F$$$^$9$,!"(B85$BG/$K$O5lM'%H!<%^%9!&%I%k%S!<$NJL%f%K%C%H!V(BDolby's Cube$B!W$K;22C!"(B89$BG/$K$O(B4th$B%"%k%P%`!V(BMarch$B!W$rH/I=!"$=$7$F:F$S3hF05Y;_$7!":rG/$K$J$C$F(B5th$B%"%k%P%`!V(BShadows and Dust$B!W$G:F;OF0$7$^$7$?!#!W(B
(2006$BG/(B08$B7n(B25$BF|(B)

MySpace.com - Lene Lovich - UK - www.myspace.com/50847998

[CD] Lene Lovich$B!X(BShadows and dust$B!Y(BStereo Society, September 13, 2005

$B!V(BThe Japanese tradition : $BF|K\$N7A(B$B!W4FFD!&5SK\!'(BNAMIKIBASHI($B>.Eg=_Fs(B/$B>.NS8-B@O:(B). 2007$BG/(B8$B7n(B17$BF|(B($B6b(B) 03:25-04:40 $B%F%l%SEl5~(B

$B4_ED=(!X(B$B13$@$i$1$N%h!<%m%C%Q@=@$3&;K(B$B!YEl5~(B : $B?7=q4[(B, 2007.3

$B2,EDEM;JIW(B$B!X$$$D$^$G$b%G%V$H;W$&$J$h!YEl5~(B : $B?7D,$B>>B<5W!XO;;~JDE9(B : $BCOJ}=PHG$N4c!YFA;3(B : $B%^%D%N=qE9(B, 1989.10.1. $BL\9u6hN)NP$,5V?^=q4[(B, 2007$BG/(B8$B7n(B18$BF|(B($BEZ(B)

$B=P5W:,C#O:!VJ83XA4=8$N0&>N!W(B. $B=P5W:,C#O:!XK\$N5$$D$1Lt!YEl5~(B : $B2O=P=qK$BF#;R!&#F!&ITFsM:(B$B!X(B$B%I%i$($b$s(B$B!Y(B($BBh(B2$B4,(B). $B>.3X4[(B, 1974.9.1 ($B$F$s$H$&Cn%3%_%C%/%9(B). 390$B1_!\>CHq@G(B5%. $BLxJ8F2(B($B5WIJJ)(B). 2007$BG/(B8$B7n(B18$BF|(B($BEZ(B)

$BF#;R!&#F!&ITFsM:(B$B!X(B$B%I%i$($b$s(B$B!Y(B($BBh(B4$B4,(B). $B>.3X4[(B, 1974.11.1 ($B$F$s$H$&Cn%3%_%C%/%9(B). 390$B1_!\>CHq@G(B5%. $BLxJ8F2(B($B5WIJJ)(B). 2007$BG/(B8$B7n(B18$BF|(B($BEZ(B)

$B2#;3BY9T(B$B!X(B$B!V$N$SB@!W$H$$$&@8$-$+$?(B$B!YEl5~(B : $B%"%9%3%`(B, 2004.12.10. $BL\9u6hN)NP$,5V?^=q4[(B, 2007$BG/(B8$B7n(B19$BF|(B($BF|(B)-20$BF|(B($B7n(B)

$B8EBe%m!<%^;K$NBg2H!&5]:oC#@h@8$,$*K4$/$J$j$K!#(B

$B@$4V(B

$B@$4V(B ($B?7=q%^%C%W!A%F!<%^$GC5$9?7=q%,%$%I!A(B)

$BO"A[=PHG$,$D$/$k(BWEB$B%^%,%8%s!N(BKAZE$B!OIw(B

$BA[!](BIMAGINE Book Search

[$BJ88%>R2p(B]$B0$It6`Li!X%O!<%a%k%s$NE+?a$-CK!Y!J>R2pBh0l2s!K(B 2006.09.10

$B=qJ*$J$-It20$O:2$J$-FyBN$N$4$H$7!#(B
"A room without books is like a body without a soul."

Ah, the famous "quote" of my beloved Tully, the moneymaking adornment of many a shirt and magnet from Amazon.com. Too bad it isn't a quote from Cicero, or any other recognized Latin author.

A gentleman came in to the library a few weeks back, and I, looking for any excuse to avoid my current research project for a few moments, watched him scour frantically through a pile of books he had collected from the stacks. Finally he admitted to the librarian that he was looking for the citation for that ubiquitous saying. A short bit of online research revealed that this quote is apocryphal (thanks to the Latin-L for this). The Latin phrase is most often rendered as ut conclave sine libris, ita corpus sine anima.

This got me to thinking about all the other things that we supposedly know were "said," but are in reality just apocrypha. A few that have always been my favorites:

"Beam me up, Scotty." - Nope, never said. The intrepid captain comes close a few times (Star Trek IV comes to mind), but never quite gets this one out there.

"Say it ain't so, Joe." - From the Chicago Herald and Examiner: after Jackson left the courthouse, "one little urchin in the crowd grabbed him by the coat sleeve. " 'It ain't true, is it?' he said. 'Yes, kid, I'm afraid it is,' Jackson replied. 'Well, I'd never have thought it,' the boy exclaimed."

"Play it again, Sam." - Bogey at his best, but he never delivers the line. Bergman does.

$B!V%f%j%$%+!W!V%(%&%l%+!W!V%X%&%l!<%+!W(B

$BHu8}M50l!X(B$B:9$,$D$/FI=q(B$B!YEl5~(B : $B3Q@n=qE9(B, 2007.6.10 ($B3Q@n(Bone$B%F!<%^(B21 ; B-95). $BL\9u6hN)NP$,5V?^=q4[(B, 2007$BG/(B8$B7n(B25$BF|(B($BEZ(B)

$B9b6651F$B;f208&5f=j(B $B;0M7Db1_D+!X??7JN_%vJ%!Y(B 2007.8.4$B46A[5-(B

$B0x2L$O$a$0$k;e$B!J$=$N#1!K(B August 14, 2007 , $B!J$=$N#2!K(B August 15, 2007

$B??7JN_%vJ%(B ($BI4G/L\(B)

$BM)NnL5$-;~Be$N2xCLOC!]1G2h!X2xCL!Y$N86:n(B ($BK\$NCn%/%i%V(B)

$BEDn49d!X(B$BN_(B($B$+$5$M(B)$B!Y(B($B4,G70m(B). $B%(%s%?!<%V%l%$%s(B, 2007.7.6 (BEAM COMIX). 690$B1_!\>CHq@G(B5%. $BITFs20=qE9(B($B<+M3$,5V(B). 2007$BG/(B8$B7n(B25$BF|(B($BEZ(B)
$B;0M7Db1_D+!X??7JN_%vJ%!Y$h$j(B $B9=@.(B $BIpEDM5L@(B

$B:#;T;R!X887nO04qk}!Y(B(2). $BFA4V=qE9(B, 2007.10.1 [8$B7n(B25$BF|(B($BEZ(B)$BH/Gd(B] (Chara comics). 533$B1_(B+$B>CHq@G(B5%. $B@D;3%V%C%/%;%s%?!<(B($B<+M3$,5VE9(B). 2007$BG/(B8$B7n(B25$BF|(B($BEZ(B)

$B:#;T;R!X887nO04qk}!Y(B[1]. $BFA4V=qE9(B, 2004.10.1 [8$B7n(B25$BF|(B($B?e(B)$BH/Gd(B] (Chara comics). 533$B1_(B+$B>CHq@G(B5%. $BK'NSF2=qE9(B($B<+M3$,5VE9(B). 2004$BG/(B8$B7n(B27$BF|(B($B6b(B)

$BM?OC>pIbL>2#6{(B$B8;;aE9!!@Z$i$lM?;0(B

$B:yI1ElJ8>O(B

$BIYBt$R$H$7!XFCL3RvS,4O%f%_%O%j!Y(B(4)=[$B40(B]. $B88E_CHq@G(B5%. $BJ865F2=qE9(B($B=BC+E9(B). 2007$BG/(B8$B7n(B25$BF|(B($BEZ(B)

$B$*$*$R$J$?$4$&!X6d2OBpG[JX%^%0%m!Y(B(2$B4,(B). $B%(%s%?!<%V%l%$%s(B, 2007.9.6 [8$B7n(B25$BF|(B($BEZ(B)$BH/Gd(B] (BEAM COMIX). 660$B1_(B+$B>CHq@G(B5%. $BJ865F2=qE9(B($B=BC+E9(B). 2007$BG/(B8$B7n(B25$BF|(B($BEZ(B)

[CD] $B7nEg$-$i$j(B starring $B5W=;>.=U(B($B%b!<%K%s%0L$B!X(B$B!y!y!y(B($B$_$D$\$7(B)$B!Y(B(10$B6J(B : 40$BJ,(B27$BIC(B). $B%"%C%W%U%m%s%H%o!<%/%9(B($B%<%F%#%^(B), 2007.2.28. EPCE-5456. 2,857$B1_(B+$B>CHq@G(B5%. $B%?%o!<%l%3!<%I(B($B=BC+E9(B). 2007$BG/(B8$B7n(B25$BF|(B($BEZ(B)

$B!X(B$B%$%s%H%-%7%1%$%H(B$B!Y(Bvol.69. $B%?%o!<%l%3!<%I(B, [2007.8.20]. $BL5NA(B. $B%?%o!<%l%3!<%I(B($B=BC+E9(B). 2007$BG/(B8$B7n(B25$BF|(B($BEZ(B)

$B%J%C%H%/Dj?)!V?^=q4[$r;H$$$3$J$=$&!*!W(B2007$BG/(B8$B7n(B25$BF|(B($BEZ(B) 18:10-18:42 NHK$BAm9g%F%l%S!X=54)$3$I$b%K%e!<%9!Y(B

$BF#?9>H?.!V(B$B72GO2;3Z%;%s%?!<(B$B!W!XD+F|?7J9!Y(B2007$BG/(B8$B7n(B26$BF|(B($BF|(B)be on Sunday, p.s7

$BD9C+@nK-M4(B$B!V(B$B9V5A;qNA!!%l%U%!%l%s%9;qNA$N2rBj(B$B!W(B $BDa8+Bg3X;J=q!&;J=qJd9V=,!!J?@.(B1$B#6G/(B9$B7n(B9$BF|(B($BLZ(B)$B!A(B10$BF|(B($B6b(B)

$BJ!2,?-0l!X(B$B@8J*$HL5@8J*$N$"$$$@(B$B!YEl5~(B : $B9VCL2007$BG/!!(B43$B:}(B

$B!V@8J*$HL5@8J*$N$"$$$@!W(B $BJ!2,?-0l(B $B9VCL $B3F=PHGJ8$KK~$A$F$$$k!#!W(B

$B%-%`!&%9%F%k%l%k%K!<(B($BGould, Stephen Jay (1996). Full house : the spread of excellence from Plato to Darwin. $B%9%F%#!<%t%s!&%8%'%$!&%0!<%k%I(B($BEOJU@/N4Lu(B)(1998)$B!X%U%k%O%&%9(B : $B@8L?$NA4MF(B : $B;M3dBGCHq@G(B5%, $BK'NSF2=qE9(B($B<+M3$,5VE9(B), 2003$BG/(B12$B7n(B6$BF|(B($BEZ(B)$B!A(B2004$BG/(B1$B7n(B5$BF|(B($B7n(B)

$B0B2,9'0l(B, $B0B2,AG;R!X(B$BJ8;zId9f$NNr;K(B. $B2$JF$HF|K\JT(B$B!YEl5~(B : $B6&N)=PHG(B, 2006.2

1888$BG/(B7$B7n(B25$BF|$N%?%$%T%s%0!&%3%s%F%9%H(B 2006$BG/(B04$B7n(B09$BF|(B

$B!V(B$B@8J*3X!&2J3X$K4X$9$k;(46(B$B$K$b(B$B%3%a%s%H(B$B$7$?$,!"(BStephen Jay Gould$B$N!X%F%/%N%m%8!<$K$*$1$k%Q%s%@$N?F;X!Y(B($B!X$,$s$P$l%+%_%J%jN5!Y(B, $BAa@n=qK<(B, 1995$BG/(B10$B7n(B, $B>e4,(Bpp.75-98$B=j<}(B)$B$K=q$+$l$F$$$k(BQWERTY$BG[Ns$K4X$9$k0oOC$O!"@5D>$J$H$3$m%^%f%D%P$@!#FC$K!"(B1888$BG/(B7$B7n(B25$BF|$N%?%$%T%s%0!&%3%s%F%9%H$K4X$9$k0J2<$N$/$@$j$O$"$^$j$K%R%I%$$N$G!"$"$($F$3$3$K=q$/$3$H$K$9$k!#!W(B

$B@FF#N60lO:!V(BStephen J. Gould$B$K$D$$$FKM$NCN$k$3$H(B$B!W(B

$B%9%F%#!<%t%s!&%8%'%$!&%0!<%k%I$NFs2s4w(B NAKAMURA Minoru's Diary (2004$BG/(B5$B7n(B) 5/20 ($BLZ(B)

$B%9%F%#!<%t%s!&%8%'%$!&%0!<%k%I(B (Stephen Jay Gould) Natural history / American Museum of Natural History (AA00310193) $BO":\(B(1973-2001.1)

• [1] Gould, Stephen Jay(1977). Ever since Darwin : reflections in natural history.
  $B%9%F%#!<%t%s!&%8%'%$!&%0!<%k%I(B($B1:K\>;5*(B, $B;{ED9cLu(B)$B!X%@!<%&%#%s0JMh(B : $B?J2=O@$X$N>7BT!Y(B($B>e(B),($B2<(B). $BEl5~(B : $BAa@n=qK<(B, 1984.2
  $B%9%F%#!<%t%s!&%8%'%$!&%0!<%k%I(B($B1:K\>;5*(B, $B;{ED9cLu(B)$B!X%@!<%&%#%s0JMh(B : $B?J2=O@$X$N>7BT!YEl5~(B : $BAa@n=qK<(B, 1995.9.30 ($B%O%d%+%oJ88K(BNF). 720$B1_(B. $BM'J~F2=qE9(B($B8c:JK\E9(B($B$D$/$P(B)), 1995$BG/(B9$B7n(B29$BF|(B($B6b(B)-11$B7n(B23$BF|(B($BLZ(B)
• [2] Gould, Stephen Jay(1980). The panda's thumb : more reflections in natural history.
  $B%9%F%#!<%t%s!&%8%'%$!&%0!<%k%I(B($B]/D.?i8.Lu(B)$B!X(B$B%Q%s%@$N?F;X(B : $B?J2=O@:F9M!Y(B($B>e(B),($B2<(B). $BEl5~(B : $BAa@n=qK<(B, 1986.5
  $B%9%F%#!<%t%s!&%8%'%$!&%0!<%k%I(B($B]/D.?i8.Lu(B)$B!X%Q%s%@$N?F;X(B : $B?J2=O@:F9M!Y(B($B>e(B),($B2<(B). $BEl5~(B : $BAa@n=qK<(B, 1996.8 ($B%O%d%+%oJ88K(BNF). 580$B1_,AW(B2. $BM'J~F2=qE9(B($B8c:JK\E9(B($B$D$/$P(B)), 1996$BG/(B8$B7n(B30$BF|(B($B6b(B)-9$B7n(B29$BF|(B($BF|(B)

  $B5lLu$rA4LLE*$K8+D>$7(B, $B=$@5$N>e(B, $BJ88K2=$7$?$b$N(B

• [3] Gould, Stephen Jay(1983). Hen's teeth and horse's toes : further reflections in natural history.
  $B%9%F%#!<%t%s!&%8%'%$!&%0!<%k%I(B($BEOJU@/N4(B, $B;0Cf?.9(Lu(B)$B!X%K%o%H%j$N;u(B : $B?J2=O@$N?7COJ?!Y(B($B>e(B),($B2<(B). $BEl5~(B : $BAa@n=qK<(B, 1988
  $B%9%F%#!<%t%s!&%8%'%$!&%0!<%k%I(B($BEOJU@/N4(B, $B;0Cf?.9(Lu(B)$B!X%K%o%H%j$N;u(B : $B?J2=O@$N?7COJ?!Y(B($B>e(B),($B2<(B). $BEl5~(B : $BAa@n=qK<(B, 1997.11.30 ($B%O%d%+%oJ88K(BNF). 680$B1_,AW(B2+$B>CHq@G(B5%. $B0020=qE9(B($BCSB^E9(B($BElIpI42_E9Fb(B)). 1997$BG/(B12$B7n(B6$BF|(B($BEZ(B)-1998$BG/(B1$B7n(B10$BF|(B($BEZ(B)
• [4] Gould, Stephen Jay(1985). The flamingo's smile : reflections in natural history.
  $B%9%F%#!<%t%s!&%8%'%$!&%0!<%k%I(B($B?7:J>$BHy>P(B($B$[$[$($_(B) : $B?J2=O@$N8=:_!Y(B($B>e(B),($B2<(B). $BEl5~(B : $BAa@n=qK<(B, 1989
  $B%9%F%#!<%t%s!&%8%'%$!&%0!<%k%I(B($B?7:J>$BHy>P(B($B$[$[$($_(B) : $B?J2=O@$N8=:_!Y(B($B>e(B),($B2<(B). $BEl5~(B : $BAa@n=qK<(B, 2002.5.31 ($B%O%d%+%oJ88K(BNF). 820$B1_,AW(B2+$B>CHq@G(B5%. $BIT20=qE9(B($B<+M3$,5V(B), 2002$BG/(B7$B7n(B3$BF|(B($B?e(B)$B!A(B27$BF|(B($BEZ(B)
• [5] Gould, Stephen Jay(1991). Bully for brontosaurus : reflections in natural history.
  $B%9%F%#!<%t%s!&%8%'%$!&%0!<%k%I(B($BW"Ln4n9,(B, $B@P66I4;^(B, $B>>K\J8M:Lu(B)$B!X$,$s$P$l%+%_%J%jN5(B : $B?J2=@8J*3X$H5n$j$f$/@8$-$b$N$?$A!Y(B($B>e(B),($B2<(B). $BEl5~(B : $BAa@n=qK<(B, 1995.10
• [6] Gould, Stephen Jay(1993). Eight little piggies : reflections in natural history
  $B%9%F%#!<%t%s!&%8%'%$!&%0!<%k%I(B($BEOJU@/N4Lu(B)$B!XH,I$$N;RFZ(B : $BJ;!!Y(B($B>e(B),($B2<(B). $BEl5~(B : $BAa@n=qK<(B, 1996.9
• [7] Gould, Stephen Jay(1995). Dinosaur in a haystack : reflections in natural history.
  $B%9%F%#!<%t%s!&%8%'%$!&%0!<%k%I(B($BEOJU@/N4Lu(B)$B!X43$7Ap$N$J$+$N62N5(B : $B2=@P>Z5r$H?J2=O@$NBgE83+!Y(B($B>e(B),($B2<(B). $BEl5~(B : $BAa@n=qK<(B, 2000.9
• [8] Gould, Stephen Jay(1998). Leonardo's mountain of clams and the Diet of Worms : essays on natural history
  $B%9%F%#!<%t%s!&%8%'%$!&%0!<%k%I(B($BEOJU@/N4Lu(B)$B!X(B$B%@!&%t%#%s%A$NFsKg3-(B : $B?J2=O@$H?MJ82J3X$N$O$6$^$G!Y(B($B>e(B),($B2<(B). $BEl5~(B : $BAa@n=qK<(B, 2002.3
• [9] Gould, Stephen Jay(2000). The lying stones of Marrakech : penultimate reflections in natural history.
  $B%9%F%#!<%t%s!&%8%'%$!&%0!<%k%I(B($BEOJU@/N4Lu(B)$B!X%^%i%1%7%e$N4f2=@P(B : $B?J2=O@$N2sO-$r$5$^$h$&2J3Xe(B),($B2<(B). $BEl5~(B : $BAa@n=qK<(B, 2005.11.30
• [10] Gould, Stephen Jay(2002). I have landed : the end of a beginning in natural history

29$B>O!V$B2<(B). $BEl5~(B : $BAa@n=qK<(B, 1996.8.31 ($B%O%d%+%oJ88K(BNF), p.183-192

Günther, B.; & Guerra, E.(1955). Biological similarities.Acta physiológica latino americana. 5, p.169-186

Stahl, W.R.(1962). Similarity and dimensional methods in biology. Science. New series. Vol.137, p.205-212

$B8eF#7r(B$B!V(B$B0[@b!V%>%&$N;~4V!!%M%:%_$N;~4V!W(B

$B!V!V%>%&$N;~4V!!%M%:%_$N;~4V(I#$B$N

$BK\@nC#M:(B$B!X(B$B%>%&$N;~4V%M%:%_$N;~4V(B : $B%5%$%:$N@8J*3X!YEl5~(B : $BCf1{8xO@ $B!V(B  $BF0J*$,JQ$o$l$P;~4V$bJQ$o$k$H$$$&$3$H$rCN$C$?$H$-$O!"?7A/$J%7%g%C%/$r46$8$?$b$N$@!#(B ... $B!#(B
  $B$3$N$H$-$O!"F0J*3X$rJY6/$7$O$8$a$F0l!;G/0J>e$?$C$F$$$?$N$G!"JL$N0UL#$G$N%7%g%C%/$bBg$-$+$C$?!#;~4V$,0c$&$H$$$&$3$H$O!"@$3&4Q$,$^$C$?$/0[$J$k$H$$$&$3$H$G$"$k!#!VAjJ$r$3$a$F=q$$$?$b$N$G$"$k!#!W!J!V$"$H$,$-!W$h$j!"(Bp.220$B!K(B

$B!V"v2N$&@8J*3X!W$r2N$*$&!*(B

$B@8J*3X%U%!%s$N%o%?%7$H$7$F$O(B $B%0!<%k%I;a$N%(%C%;%$=8$b3Z$7$_$N0l$D$G$9!#(B $B%U%!%s$H$$$$$D$D(B $BFI$_Mn$H$7$F$$$?$N$,(B $B!X%Q%s%@$N?F;X!Y%O%d%+%o=qK<$G$9!#(B $B8EK\20$G 29$B>O!I $B$3$NFbMF$,!"$^$5$K!X%>%&$N;~4V!"%M%:%_$N;~4V!Y(B $B$G$"$j$^$9!#(B $BK\@n@h@8$N$"$H$,$-(B $B@8$-$b$N$K$h$C$F;~4V$,0c$&$H$$$&;v $B@8J*3X$r3X$S$@$7$F(B10$BG/0J>e$?$C$?$"$H!"(B $B$H$$$&%U%l!<%:$H=E$J$j$^$9!#(B   $B$d$O$j$3$&$$$&FbMF$O(B $B%"%a%j%+$G$O $B@8$-J*$N5$;}$A$K$J$C$F(B $B9M$($F$_$k$H$$$&$N$O(B $B?M$H$=$NB>@8$-$b$N$H$N9B$,Bg$-$$2$JF?M$K$O(B $B

$B$"$($F1Q8l8xMQ8lO@(B 2000/08/26

$B=PHG6H3&$K4X$9$kK\(B (wad's $BFI=q%a%b(B)

$BBh(B92$B2s@$3&%(%9%Z%i%s%HBg2q(B 2007$BG/(B $B2#IM(B

$BGr@PL@I'!V(B$B!V%(%9%Z%i%s%H!WCB@8#1#2#0G/!!8@8l9M$($k=q@R$dBg2q(B$B!W!XD+F|?7J9!Y(B2007$BG/(B8$B7n(B30$BF|(B($BLZ(B) $BD+4)(B, p.32

$B\%?^;V0[(B

• $BEl2mIW(B($BJT(B)$B!X3)@nN6G72pME2xJ83X4[!YEl5~(B : $B3X=,8&5f$B!X3)@nN6G72pA4=8!YBh(B23$B4,(B. $BEl5~(B : $B4dGH=qE9(B, 1998

$B8bCR1Q!X%^%s%,68$K$D$1$kLt(B. $B2<3X>eC#JS!Y%a%G%#%"%U%!%/%H%j!<(B, 2007.6.1. $BL\9u6hN)NP$,5V?^=q4[(B, 2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B1$BF|(B($BEZ(B)

$B4d0f;VKc;R(B$B!XL5=}$N0&!YAPMU$BAu2h!&A^$73((B $BGrIMH~@iBe(B

$B!V(B$BFs$D$N4i(B$B!W(BCopie conforme. 1947$BG/!"%U%i%s%9!"%8%c%s!&%I%l%t%#%k(B(Jean Dreville)$B4FFD(B

$B!V(B$B%W%i!<%0$NBg3X@8(B$B!W(BDer Student von Prag. 1913$BG/!"%I%$%D!"%7%e%F%i%s!&%i%$(B(Stellan Rye)$B4FFD(B
$B%O%s%9!&%O%$%s%D!&%(!<%t%!!<%9(B(Hanns Heinz Ewers)$B5SK\(B

• $B%j%a%$%/(B:
  • 1926$BG/(B$B!"%I%$%D!"%X%s%j%C%/!&%,%l!<%s(B(Henrik Galeen)$B4FFD(B
  • 1935$BG/!"%I%$%D!"%"%k%H%%!<%k!&%m%S%=%s(B(Arthur Robison)$B4FFD(B
• $B%N%Y%i%$%:(B:
  • $B%O%s%9!&%O%$%s%D!&%(%(%&%(%k%9(B[$B:n(B] $B!V%W%i%"%0$NBgU\@8!W(B. $B%I%*%G%((B[$B$[$+Cx(B] ; $B?Al45Hl#!X;b;R%KJS!YEl5~(B : $B2~B$H.H.$B%(!<%t%'%k%9Cx(B ; $BA0@nF;2pLu!X%W%i!<%/$NBg3X@8!YEl5~(B : $BEl5~AO85
  • $B86:n(B: Poe, Edgar Allan(1839). William Wilson$B!V%&%#%j%"%`!&%&%#%k%=%s!W(B
• $B%]!(B) $B@V;`IB$N2>LL!&%"%C%7%c!<2H$NJx2u!&%b%k%039$N;&?M!&%&%#%j%"%`(B-$B%&%#%k%=%s!YEl5~(B : $B2"J8 $B!V(B  $BJ*8l$NE55r$O(B$B%o%7%s%H%s!&%"!<%S%s%0(B$B$,0lH,;0O;G/$NG/4)!X%.%U%H=8!Y$K$N$;$?!V?M$NCN$i$J$$%P%$%m%s6*$N7`!W$G!"%"!<%S%s%0$N@bL@$K$h$k$H!"$3$NOC$r$7$?%a%I%&%#%s$O%P%$%m%s<+?H$+$iJ9$$$?$N$@$H$$$&!#$9$J$o$A%9%Z%$%s$N5.B2%I%s!&%"%k%U%)%s%>$,7c>p$N$*$b$`$/$^$^$KA08e$N8+$5$+$$$b$J$/9TF0$7$F!"$D$$$K?H$r$[$m$\$9$H$$$C$?J*8l$G$"$k!#!W!J4"ED85;J!V2r@b!W$h$j!"(Bp.219$B!K(B

Hesse, Hermann(1905). Der Lateinschuler. $B%X%k%^%s!&%X%C%;:n(B($B9q>>9'FsLu(B)$B!V%i%F%s8l3X9;@8!W(B. $B>.3$1JFs(B($BJT.@b!YEl5~(B : $B@5?J\(B] ($B@5?J$B:#;T;R!XKM$N$d$5$7$$$*7;$5$s!Y(B(1). $BK'J8CHq@G(B5%. $BEl5^%9%H%"(B($B<+M3$,5VE9(B). 2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B2$BF|(B($BF|(B)

$B!V%*!<%1%9%H%i$O?M$r$D$/$k(B : $B%Y%M%:%(%i$N%f!<%9!&%*!<%1%9%H%i!W(B Tocar y luchar. 2005$BG/!"%Y%M%:%(%i!"(BCinema Sur & Explorart Films$B@):n!"(B $B4FFD(B: $B%"%k%Y%k%H!&%"%k%Y%m(B Alberto Arvelo.
2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B3$BF|(B($B7n(B) 00:55-02:12 NHK BS2$B!X%/%i%7%C%/!&%m%$%d%k%7!<%H!Y%/%i%7%C%/%I%-%e%a%s%?%j!<(B
$B=P1i(B: $B%[%;!&%"%s%H%K%*!&%"%V%l%&(B José Antonio Abreu $B!J(Bpresidente de FESNOJIV (Fundación del Estado para el Sistema Nacional de las Orquestas Juveniles e Infantiles de Venezuela) $B%Y%M%:%(%i@D>/G/!&;yF8%*!<%1%9%H%iA49q@)EY:bCD!K!"(B $B%0%9%?!<%\!&%I%%%@%a%k(B Gustavo Dudamel$B!"$[$+(B

$B;32$B!V(B$BJ83XIt$G3X$s$@$3$H(B : $B#1#0#0G/@h$N@$3&$N$?$a$K!W!X5~ETBg3XJ83XIt#1#0#0<~G/5-G0;o!Y=j<}(B

$B%*%:%\!<%s!&%3%l%/%7%g%s(B ($B8EK\!!3$$M$3(B)

$BsnF#>:!X%o%7%s%H%s!&%"!<%t%#%s%0$H$=$N;~Be!YEl5~(B : $BK\$NM'$B%]!<(B($B>.@n9b5ALu(B)$B!X9uG-(B ; $B%b%k%039$N;&?M(B : $BB>(B6$BJT!YEl5~(B : $B8wJ8Shakespeare, William(1599). Julius Caesar. $B%7%'%$%/%9%T%"(B ; $B0B@>E0M:Lu!X%8%e%j%"%9!&%7!<%6!N$B!&%l!<%J%&(B($B9O:Lu(B)$B!V;m=8!W(B[$B>6(B]. $B8bLP0l(B [$B$[$+(B] ($BJT(B)$B!X@$3&L>;m=8Bg@.!Y(B6: $B%I%$%DJS(B, 1. $BEl5~(B : $BJ?K^$B>>2,@59d!X$A$g$C$HK\5$$J@iLk@i:}8W$N4,(B : $BFI=q=QLH5v3'EA!YEl5~(B : $B5aN6F2(B, 2007.6.27. $BL\9u6hN)NP$,5V?^=q4[(B, 2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B8$BF|(B($BEZ(B)

$BHS_7J8IW!VB"=q$N;`:](B ([$BFC=8(B] $B=8=q$H@0M}(B)$B!W!XF|K\8E=qDL?.!Y(B63(9), p.20-21 (1998.9)

$B!V(B  $BBg3X?^=q4[$K6PL3$7$F$$$F!"?4DK$a$k$3$H$N0l$D$K!"DjG/B`?&$r7^$($?650w$+$i!"$J$$$7$O$=$N8e$KK4$/$J$i$l$?650w$N0dB2$+$i?=$7=P$i$l$kB"=q4sB#$X$NBP1~$,$"$k!#(B
  $BH>@$5*$K5Z$V3X5f@83h$rAw$C$?!"$H$j$o$1J82J7O$N650w$N85$K$O!"K|C10L$NB"=q$,C_@Q$5$l$k%1!<%9$,>/$J$/$J$$!#8=Lr$G%P%j%P%j$H3hLv$7$F$$$?;~J,$K$O$=$l$G$bB-$j$J$+$C$?$b$N$,!"0l@~$rB`$$$?$H$?$s$K!VLq2p$JBeJ*!W$H2=$7$F$7$^$C$?!"$HC2B)$rO3$i$5$l$?650w$,$$$?!#(B
  $B$^$7$F$d0dB2$K$H$C$F$O!"$7$P$i$/$O;W$$=P$d82>4$N5$;}$A$+$i$=$N$^$^$K$7$F$*$/$b$N$N!"B"=q$r0z$-7Q$0F1$8J,Ln$N8&5f$k$b$N$K$J$k!#!W(B(p.20)

$B!V(B  $B$7$+$7$J$,$i!"$@$+$i$H$$$C$FEv?M$d0dB2$K$7$F$_$l$P!"@836$r$+$1$F<}=8$7!"<+?H$N3XLd7A@.$r;Y$(!"6l3Z$r6&$K$7$F$-$?$H$$$C$F$$$$B"=q$r!"$=$&$*$$$=$l$H=hJ,$9$k$N$O$?$a$i$o$l$k!#$=$3$G$;$a$F!"9|$rKd$a$?Bg3X$N8e3X$N$?$a$KLrN)$F$i$l$l$P!"$H9M$(;j$k$N$OEvA3$N@.9T$-$G$"$k!#(B
  $B$H$3$m$,:r:#!"B?$/$NBg3X?^=q4[$O!"$3$N  $B[)!";DG0$J$s$G$9$,=q8K$,K~GU$G<}MF$NM>CO$,$"$j$^$;$s!#(B
  $B[)!"@Z$J$$$3$H$K?M  $B$G!"7k2L$H$7$F$O!"0lHV9%$^$7$$$N$,!"I,MW$J=qJ*$@$1$rCj=P$5$;$FD:$/$3$H!#l$N>r7o$r0{$s$GLc$&$3$H!#$=$l$r$^$:A0Ds$H$7$F!"?=$7=P$r

$B!VB?$/$NBg3X?^=q4[$G!"ApAO4|$dElBgF1MM$K?L:R$d@o:R$+$i$N:F6=4|$J$I!"$H$K$+$/B"=q$rA}$d$9$3$H$K5b!9$H$7$F$$$?;~4|$K$O!"$I$3$N?^=q4[$b650w$d4X78$r4'$7$?J88K$r@_CV$7$?$b$N$@!#8X$i$7$2$KJ88KL\O?$r:n@.$7!"FC  $B$=$&$7$?;~Be$+$i9M$($l$P!"8=:_$N>u67$O3V@$$N46$,$"$k!#B?$/$NBg3X?^=q4[$G!"I,$:$7$bK~B-$9$k$Y$-$G$O$J$$$K$7$F$b!"B"=q$,$=$l$J$j$K=<u67$K6a$E$$$F$$$k>Z5r$G$b$"$m$&$+!#$^$7$F:#$d!"Bg3X?^=q4[3&$O%M%C%H%o!<%/$dAj8_6(NO$,0lHL2=$7$F!"B"=q$NNL$r6%$&;~Be$G$b$J$/$J$C$?!#(B
  $B8&5fo$NA*=q4p=`$+$i30$l$k$b$N$,B?$/4^$^$l$k!#B?>/I}$r$b$?$;$?$H$7$F$b!"  $B@^3QBg;v$K$7$F$-$?0&B"=q$r!"$=$N$h$&$K$D$^$_?)$$$r$5$l$F$O$?$^$i$J$$!"$I$3$+0l3g$7$F0z$-l9g$NJ}$,$[$C$H$5$;$i$l$k!#(B
  $B?4DK$`$N$O!"$`$7$m?^=q4[$N8@$$J,$K42Bg$JM}2r$r<($7$F$/$l$?;~$G$"$k!#1&$+$i:8$KA*JL$7!"Cj=P$5$l$?=qJ*$O?^=q4[$N0lHL=q$NCf$K:.:_2=$5$l!";D$j$NBgB??t$O!"Fb30$N?^=q4[$H$N8r49?^=q$K=P$5$l$k$+!"3X@8$X$N%j%5%$%/%k?^=q$H$5$l$k$+!"$O$?$^$?8E=qE9$KGd5Q$5$l$k$+!"$$$:$l$K$;$h0lBe$+$1$F<}=8$7$?B"=q$NBN7O$O1@;6L8>C$9$k!#$3$N;~$[$I!"B"=q$N1?L?$N$"$o$l$r46$8$k$3$H$O$J$$!#!W(B(p.21)

$B@>86OB3$!V%&%s%A$K$9$k(B ([$BFC=8(B] $B=8=q$H@0M}(B)$B!W!XF|K\8E=qDL?.!Y(B63(9), p.19-20 (1998.9)

$B!V(B  $BFI=q$O!"$h$/?)9T0Y$KSH$($i$l$k!#K\$rL#$o$&!"RrSp!&>C2=$9$k$H$$$C$?$h$&$J8@$$J}$G$"$k!#$7$+$7!"$=$NGS]u$K$^$G8@5Z$5$l$k$3$H$O!"$"$^$j0lHLE*$K8+$+$1$J$$$h$&$@!W(B(p.19)
$B!V(B  $B$H$K$+$/!"FI$`$3$H$K$D$-$h$&!#$=$&$9$l$P!"$*$N$:$+$iK\$O8:$C$F$$$/!W(B(p.20)

$BC.8+Gn!X8EK\DL(B : $B;T>l!&C5:w!&B"=q$NL%NO!YEl5~(B : $BJ?K^ $B!V@h$NFC=8(B [$B!V=8=q$H@0M}!W!XF|K\8E=qDL?.!Y(B63(7,8,9) 1998$BG/(B7,8,9$B7n9f(B] $B$G!"L4Ln5W:n$dK~=#$J$I5l?"L1COJ82=$N8&5f86OB3$$5$s$,!"!VFI=q$O!"$h$/?)9T0Y$KSH$($i$l$k!#K\$rL#$o$&!"RrSp!&>C2=$9$k$H$$$C$?$h$&$J8@$$J}$G$"$k!#$7$+$7!"$=$NGS]u$K$^$G8@5Z$5$l$k$3$H$O!"$"$^$j0lHLE*$K$O8+$+$1$J$$$h$&$@!W$H$$$$!"!V$H$K$+$/!"FI$`$3$H$K$D$-$h$&!#$=$&$9$l$P!"$*$N$:$+$iK\$O8:$C$F$$$/!W!"K\Ev$K<+J,$KI,MW$JK\$r8+6K$a!"B"=qNL$r;0@i:}$H7h$a!"$"$H$O8EK\20$XGd$k$J$j!";(;o$J$I$OI,MW$J$H$3$m$@$1@Z$j

$B!V(B  $B@>86$5$s$N=q$/$h$&$K!"Gc$C$?K\$OFI$s$G!"ITMW$JK\$O=hJ,$7$F$$$1$P$$$$$N$@$,!"8EK\$rGc$&$3$H$,/$J$$$N$G$O$J$$$+$H;W$&!#DI$$$D$/?M$OK\9%$-$G$O$J$/$F!"FI=q9%$-$J$N$G$"$k!#!VGc$&$KDI$$$D$/FI=q?M$J$7!W$H$b8@$&$i$7$$!J1|K\Bg;0O:!V?^=q4[7y$$$NJ[!W!"!XCn$N$p$I$3$m!Y=j<}!K!#!W(B(p.135)

$B!V(B  $B4pK\E*$K$OK\$r0&$9$k?M!9$O=qJ*$rBg@Z$K07$C$F$-$?!#$7$+$7!"?M$K$h$C$F$OL5;4$@$J$H;W$&$h$&$Jp$"$k!W0z$-J}$,$"$k$h$&$K;W$&$N$G$"$k!#(B
  $BK4$/$J$C$F$=$N2?@i:}$+$NB"=q$,8E=q;T>l$K4DN.$9$k$3$H$O$h$/$"$k$3$H$@$,!"$=$N$3$H$4$H$/$,1tI.$N%i%$%s$@$i$1$H$$$&J}$,$$$?!#;d$,07$C$?$N$G$O$J$$$N$@$,!"$h$/B8$8>e$2$F$$$?J}$G!"$=$N8e!"8EK\20$N6Q0lBf$G!"DA$7$$K\$J$N$K0B$$$J$H;W$$!"e$2$FK\$r3+$/$H!"$=$l$HJ,$+$k1tI.$N%i%$%s$@$i$1$G$"$C$?$H$$$&$3$H$,$7$P$i$/B3$$$?!#2?$N$?$a$K%i%$%s$r$"$l$[$I6/$/0z$+$J$1$l$P$J$i$J$$$N$+!";d$OM}2r$K6l$7$`!#!W(B(p.152-153)

$B668}8tG72p!XOBK\F~Lg(B : $B@iG/@8$-$k=qJ*$N@$3&!YEl5~(B : $BJ?K^[CD] $B%7%^%N%U%9%-(B (Szymanowski, Karol, 1882-1937)$B!X%t%!%$%*%j%s$H%T%"%N$N$?$a$N2;3Z!Y(BNAXOS, 2007$BG/(B6$B7n(B. 8.557748 (6$B6J(B : 76$B!l(B45$B!m(B). $B@G9~(B1,040$B1_(B. $B%?%o!<%l%3!<%I(B($B?7=IE9(B). 2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B8$BF|(B($BEZ(B)
$B1iAU(B: $B%_%j%"%`!&%/%l%$%^!<(B($B%t%!%$%*%j%s(B), $B%K%3%i%9!&%@!<%+%s(B($B%T%"%N(B)
$B!JO?2;(B: 2005$BG/(B6$B7n(B $B%$%.%j%9!"%5%U%)!<%/!"%]%C%H%s!&%[!<%k!K(B
$BFbMF(B:

1. $B%t%!%$%*%j%s!&%=%J%?(B $B%KC;D4(B Op.9 (1904)(24$B!l(B12$B!m(B)
2. $B%"%$%?%3!&%(%K%"$N;R$B?@OC(B : 3$B$D$N;m(B Op.30 (1915)(23$B!l(B34$B!m(B)
3. $B%m%^%s%9(B $B%KD9D4(B Op.23 (1910)(6$B!l(B31$B!m(B)
4. $BLkA[6J$H%?%i%s%F%i(B Op.28 (1915)(12$B!l(B28$B!m(B)
5. $B2N7`!V%m%8%'2&!W(B(1924)$B$h$j%m%/%5!<%L$N2N(B($B%3%O%K%9%-JT6J(B)(5$B!l(B35$B!m(B)

[CD] $B%^%k%F%#%L!<(B. $B%T%"%N8^=EAU6J(B $BBh(B1$BHV!&Bh(B2$BHV(B $BB>(B. NAXOS, 2007$BG/(B7$B7n(B. 8.557861. (58$B!l(B33$B!m(B). $B@G9~(B1,040$B1_(B. $B%?%o!<%l%3!<%I(B($B?7=IE9(B). 2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B8$BF|(B($BEZ(B)

$BFbMF(B:

1. $B%T%"%N8^=EAU6JBh(B1$BHV(B (1933)(17$B!l(B51$B!m(B)
2. $B%T%"%N8^=EAU6JBh(B2$BHV(B (1944)(28$B!l(B28$B!m(B)
3. 2$B$D$N%t%!%$%*%j%s$H%T%"%N$N$?$a$N%=%J%?(B (1932)(12$B!l(B14$B!m(B)

$BO?2;(B: 2005$BG/(B6$B7n(B $B%A%'%3!"%W%i%O!"%A%'%3!&%i%8%*!&%9%?%8%*(B1

$B1iAU(B: $B%^%k%F%#%L!<;M=EAUCD(B ; $B%+%l%k!&%3%7%c!<%l%/(B($B%T%"%N(B)

[CD] Skeleton Crew. "Learn to talk" (1984) ; "The country of blinds" (1986). (20$B6J(B : 75$B!l(B48). RecRec($B%9%$%9(B), reCDec 512, 1989$BG/(B
$B"*(B [$BA}Jd2~D{(B]: $B%9%1%k%H%s!&%/%k!Locus Solus($BF|K\(B), LSI 2084/5 $B"+(B RER(UK), ReR FRO 8/9. 4,800$B1_(B+$B>CHq@G(B5%. $B%?%o!<%l%3!<%I(B($B?7=IE9(B). 2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B8$BF|(B($BEZ(B)

$B$&$5$.$d(B $B$I$i$d$-(B 180$B1_(B, $B4n:n:GCf(B 90$B1_(B

$B!V>.Ln%j%5!!%3%s%5!<%H#2#0#0#7(B : $B%"%s%H%K%*!&%+%k%m%9!&%8%g%S%s$KJ{$0!W(B2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B8$BF|(B($BEZ(B) 23:30-9$BF|(B($BF|(B) 01:00 NHK BS2
$B>.Ln%j%5(B, $B%Q%&%m!&%8%g%S%s(B, $B%@%K%(%k!&%8%g%S%s(B, $B%_%&%7%c(B, $B%/%j%9!&%7%k%P!<%9%?%$%s(B, $B@P@nCR(B, $B0f>e?.J?(B, $BA0EDA1I'(B
(2007$BG/(B8$B7n(B18$BF|(B($BEZ(B) , $BF|HfC+Ln302;3ZF2(B) Lisa Ono 2007 Sunset Bossa - Tribute to Antonio Carlos Jobim

$B8r6A;m!V1QM:$N@836!W!]6J$N35MW!J$=$N#1!K!](B / $BJ8!'(B $B>e3A(B $BBYJ?!J%Q!<%+%C%7%g%s!K(B ; $B9=@.!&0lItJdI.!'(B $B4dED(B $BNQOB!J%A%'%m!K(B($B4X@>%7%F%#%U%#%k%O!<%b%K!<8r6A3ZCD(B) 2005.8.14$B:n@.(B

$B8r6A;m!V(B$B%I%s!&%U%"%s(B$B!W:nIJ(B20 ($B%j%R%c%k%H!&%7%e%H%i%&%9(B) 1887-1888$BG/:n6J!"(B1889$BG/(B11$B7n(B11$BF|=i1i(B
$B%K%3%i%&%9!&%l!<%J%&(B (Nicolaus Lenau 1802-1850$B!K$N;m(B(1844$BG/Bh(B3$B2s=$@5(B)$B$K$h$k(B

R.$B%7%e%H%i%&%9(B $B8r6A;m!V%I%s!&%U%!%s!W(BOp.20 ($B6JL\2r@b(B | $B%3%s%5!<%H!&%*%V!&%3%s%5!<%D(B | NTT$B%G!<%?(B)

$B!V==;0$N4i$r;}$DCK!!0KC0==;0$KGw$k!W(B2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B9$BF|(B($BF|(B) 12:15-14:00 NHK FM$B!XF|MK5JCc<oO"!"%I%$%DJ83X.@tM5H~;R(B($B%&%'%$%H%l%9(B)

$B2.LnJ8I'(B($BJTCx(B)$B!X?)$N4o$N;vE5!YEl5~(B : $B$B%U%#%s%,!<%\%&%k(B ($B%U%j!$B%&%#%-%Z%G%#%"(B$B!J(BWikipedia$B!K!Y(B)

$B9SLZDgIW$,N&73Bg>-$@$C$?:"$Ke!"5R$N0l?M$,%U%#%s%,!<%\%&%k$N;HMQK!$rCN$i$:!"Cf$N?e$r0{$s$G$7$^$C$?!#$9$k$H9SLZ$O!"RtSM$K<+J,$b%U%#%s%,!<%\%&%k$N?e$r0{$_!"

$BFG!z%]%(%`!t(B41 $B%U%#%s%,!<%\!<%k(B

3.$B%U%#%s%,!<%\!<%k(B ($B3t<02q $B0oOC=8(B)

$BNSUi!X(B$B:nK!?4F@(B$B!Y(B1981, $BBh(B14$B@a!!:nK!E*$J$D$b$j$GL5:nK!$r9T$J$&

$B65$($F!*(Bgoo QNo.1098623 $B%U%#%s%,!<%\!<%k$N?e$r0{$s$8$c$&J*8l(B ANo.3

$BF1$8OC$+$I$&$+$o$+$i$J$$$N$G$9$,!"2FL\^{@P$N!V8cGZ$OG-$G$"$k!W$NCf$G!"Hs>o$K$h$/;w$?OC$K$D$$$F8@5Z$,$"$j$^$9!#Bh==0l>O$G!V8cGZ!W$N

$B2FL\^{@P!X(B$B8cGZ$OG-$G$"$k(B$B!Y(B

$B1Q9q$NE7;R$,(B$B0uEY(B$B!J(B$B%$%s%I(B$B!K(B$B$XM7$S$K9T$C$F!"0uEY$N2&B2$H?)Bn$r6&$K$7$?;~$K!"$=$N2&B2$,E7;R$NA0$H$b?4$E$+$:$K!"$D$$<+9q$N2fN.$r=P$7$F(B$BGONk=r(B$B!J(B$B$8$c$,$$$b(B$B!K(B$B$r(B$B$B!J(B$B$F$E$+(B$B!K(B$B$_$G;.$X$H$C$F!"$"$H$+$i(B$B??@V(B$B!J(B$B$^$C$+(B$B!K(B$B$K$J$C$F(B$BXC(B$B!J(B$B$O(B$B!K(B$B$8F~$C$?$i!"E7;R$OCN$i$s4i$r$7$F$d$O$jFsK\;X$GGONk=r$r;.$X$H$C$?$=$&$@!D!D!W(B
$B!V$=$l$,1Q5HMx $B!VKM$O$3$s$JOC$rJ9$$$?!W$H$B8e(B$B!J(B$B$"$H(B$B!K(B$B$r$D$1$k!#!V$d$O$j1Q9q$N$"$kJ<1D$GN~Bb$N;N41$,Bg@*$7$F0l?M$N2<;N41$r8fCZAv$7$?;v$,$"$k!#8fCZAv$,:Q$s$G$B>K;RH-(B$B!J(B$B%,%i%9$P$A(B$B!K(B$B$XF~$l$F=P$7$?$i!"$3$N2<;N41$O1c2q$K$J$l$s$H8+$($F!">K;RH-$r8}$X$"$F$FCf$N?e$r$0$&$H0{$s$G$7$^$C$?!#$9$k$HN~BbD9$,FMA32<;N41$N7r9/$r=K$9$H1>$$$J$,$i!"$d$O$j%U(B$B%R(B$B%s%,!$BJB(B$B!J(B$B$J(B$B!K(B$B$_$$$k;N41$b2fNt$i$8$H(B$B?eGV(B$B!J(B$B$_$:$5$+$:$-(B$B!K(B$B$r5s$2$F2<;N41$N7r9/$r=K$7$?$H1>$&$

$B!V8cGZ$OG-$G$"$k!W(B: $BA^2h$G$D$E$k^{@P$NG-(B

$B2FL\^{@P(B($BJ8(B) ; $BIpEDH~Jf(B($B3((B) ; $Bc7F#9'(B($BJT(B)$B!X8cGZ$OG-$G$"$k!YEl5~(B : $B$[$k$W=PHG(B, 2006.1.15 ($B@<$K$@$9$3$H$P$($[$s(B). $BL\9u6hN)NP$,5V?^=q4[(B, 2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B15$BF|(B($BEZ(B)

$B9VCL$B0BF#J8?M(B$B!V(B$B!V3$AM$NMM$JJ8>O!W$H$O2?$+(B : $B!X8cGZ$OG-$G$"$k!Y$H!R%"%J%H%_!

$BFbED>!(B$B!V(B$BEEG>6u4V$N%m!<%l%s%9!&%9%?!<%s(B$B!W(B

$BB<>e?.IW!XDk9q%[%F%k?_K$BB<>e?.IW!XDk9q%[%F%k?_K$B!V2!F~$l$N$A$h!W(B($BA4(B5$B2s(B). 2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B10$BF|(B($B7n(B)-14$BF|(B($B6b(B) 22:45-23:00 NHK FM$B!X@D=U%"%I%Y%s%A%c! $B86:n!'2.869@!X(B$B2!F~$l$N$A$h(B$B!Y?7D,$B5S?'!'IMED=(:H!"A*6J!'0KF#_7=SI'!"5;=Q!';eNS70!"8z2L!'JFK\K~(B
$BBh#12s!!!V2!F~$l$N$A$h!W!"Bh#22s!!!V<7F|4V!W!J86Bj!'!VO7G-!W!K!"Bh#32s!!!VLZ2<0G!W!"Bh#42s!!!V;&0U$N%l%7%T!W!"Bh#52s!!!V%3!<%k!W(B

$B4AJ8$K$D$$$F(B(1) ($B$^$s$I$%!<$+(B$B$N(B$B%5%s%9%/%j%C%H!&%Z!<%8(B)

$B>>K\=_!V(B$BF|K\4AJ8$X$N$$$6$J$$(B $BBh0lIt!!F|K\J82=$H4A;z!&4AJ8(B $BBhFs>O!!4AJ8$HCf9q8l(B $B!J#4!KCf9q8l2;FI$N ($BF|K\4AJ8$N@$3&(B)

$B2CF#E0!X(B$B4AJ8$NAGM\(B : $BC/$,F|K\J82=$r$D$/$C$?$N$+!)!YEl5~(B : $B8wJ8 $B!V(B  $B4AJ8$,!V@8;::b$H$7$F$N65M\!W$@$C$?9>8M;~Be$G$b!"%W%m$N4A3X8M$N(B$BGPk_(B($B$O$$$+$$(B)$B;U$d(B$BH82H(B($B$O$J$7$+(B)$B$O4AJ8$+$i%M%?$r;EF~$l!"0ep$r>\$7$/CN$k$3$H$,$G$-$?!#!W(B(p.232)

$B!V(B  $B$=$b$=$b@N$N4A;zJ82=7w$G$O!"0ep;m$@$1$N!"C1D4$J$b$N$@$H8m2r$7$F$7$^$&$@$m$&!#!W(B(p233)

$BC$L&=m!X(B$B!V$B!Y?7Au!&A}JdHG(B. $BEl5~(B : $BJuEg$BC$L&=mCx!X(B$B!VJk$i$9(B!$B!W5;=Q(B$B!YEl5~(B : $BJuEg$BC$L&=m!X$b$&0lEY!V$BC$L&=m!X(B$B$b$&0lEY!V$B!YEl5~(B : $BJuEg$BD9M'@iBe<#!X9>8M;~Be$N=qJ*$HFI=q!YEl5~(B : $BEl5~F2=PHG(B, 2001.3.5. $BL\9u6hN)NP$,5V?^=q4[(B, 2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B15$BF|(B($BEZ(B)

$BEDCf=(!X(B$B4AJ8$+$iCf9q8l$X$NF;(B : $B8lK!Nc2r!&Cf9q2;Cm!YEl5~(B : $B1JOB8l3X$B!X;m$,Bg$9$-$K$J$k!YEl5~(B : $B>.3X4[(B, 1999.11.20 ($B%I%i$($b$s$N3X=,%7%j!<%:(B . $B%I%i$($b$s$N9q8l$*$b$7$m96N,(B). $B;XF3(B: $B?eFb4n5WM:(B

$B66K\<#(B$B!X%O%7%b%H<08EE5F~Lg(B : $B$3$l$G8EE5$,$h$/$o$+$k!YEl5~(B : $B$4$^=qK<(B, 1997.11 ($B%4%^%V%C%/%9(B)
$B"*(B [$B2~Bj(B]:$B!X(B$B$3$l$G8EE5$,$h$/$o$+$k(B$B!YEl5~(B : $BC^K`=qK<(B, 2001.12.10 ($B$A$/$^J88K(B). 680$B1_!\>CHq@G(B5%. $B;0>JF2=qE9(B($BBg4]%T!<%3%C%/<+M3%v5VE9(B). 2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B16$BF|(B($BF|(B)-18$BF|(B($B2P(B)

$BL\O?%7%9%F%`%3!<%G%#%s%0%^%K%e%"%k(B $BIUO?(B4 $BAL5ZF~NO;X?K(B

$B!VAL5ZF~NO;X?K!W$N1?MQ$K$D$$$F(B$B!X%*%s%i%$%s!&%7%9%F%`!&%K%e!<%9%l%?!$B!V(B$BBh#34|AL5ZF~NO;v6H#5%uG/7W2h$NL\I8C#@.!*(B $B7QB3$7$FBh#44|AL5ZF~NO;v6H#5%uG/7W2h$,3+;O$5$l$^$7$?(B$B!W!X(B$B\@0~(B$B!Y(B($BKL3$F;Bg3XImB0?^=q4[Js(B) 110$B9f(B (2001.7)

$B!V(B$B=q;o>pJs%G!<%?%Y!<%9(B(OPAC) ($B%7%j!<%:!&EE;R?^=q4[$N8=>u(B (1))$B!W!X(B$B$D$/$P$M(B : $BC^GHBg3X?^=q4[Js!Y(B27(1), p.12-13 (2001.6)

$BFC=8!VAL5ZF~NO$H;qNADs6!!W!X8=Be$N?^=q4[!Y(B29(2), p.67-115 (1991.6)

• $BCf@>M5!VAa0pEDBg3X?^=q4[$K$*$1$kOB=qAL5ZF~NO(B ($BFC=8(B $BAL5ZF~NO$H;qNADs6!(B)$B!W!X8=Be$N?^=q4[!Y(B29(2), p.67-72 (1991.6)
• $BLpLn8wM:(B, $BCfLnH~CR;R!V?^=q4[;qNA$N%a%G%#%"JQ49$H>pJsDs6!%5!<%S%9(B : $B2,;3Bg3XCSED2HJ88K%^%$%/%m2=$N>l9g(B ($BFC=8(B $BAL5ZF~NO$H;qNADs6!(B)$B!W!X8=Be$N?^=q4[!Y(B29(2), p.73-80 (1991.6)
• $BA}0f$f$&;R!V8EE5@RAm9gL\O?%G(B-$B%?%Y(B-$B%9$N7A@.(B ($BFC=8(B $BAL5ZF~NO$H;qNADs6!(B)$B!W!X8=Be$N?^=q4[!Y(B29(2), p.81-90 (1991.6)
• $BLZI69/G7!V!VAL5Z!W$K$*$1$k:n6He$N=tLdBj(B ($BFC=8(B $BAL5ZF~NO$H;qNADs6!(B)$B!W!X8=Be$N?^=q4[!Y(B29(2), p.91-98 (1991.6)
• $B1Q9q?^=q4[(BISTC$BJT=8<<(B($BCx(B), $B@cEh9(0l(B($BLu(B)$B!V%G(B-$B%?%Y(B-$B%9(BISTC$B$K$D$$$F(B ($BFC=8(B $BAL5ZF~NO$H;qNADs6!(B)$B!W!X8=Be$N?^=q4[!Y(B29(2), p.99-104 (1991.6)
• $B1JED<#MN8E4)K\$K4X$9$kAm9gL\O?%G!<%?%Y!<%9$N7A@.(B ($BFC=8(B $BAL5ZF~NO$H;qNADs6!(B)$B!W!X8=Be$N?^=q4[!Y(B29(2), p.105-115 (1991.6)

$BFC=8!V?^=q4[L\O?$NAL5ZJQ49!W!X>pJs$N2J3X$H5;=Q!Y(B42(3), p.197-250 (1992.3)

• $B!V(B$BFC=8!V?^=q4[L\O?$NAL5ZJQ49!W$NJT=8$K$"$?$C$F(B ($BFC=8(B $B?^=q4[L\O?$NAL5ZJQ49(B)$B!W!X>pJs$N2J3X$H5;=Q!Y(B42(3), p.197 (1992.3)
• $B5m:j?J!V(B$B$o$,9q$K$*$1$kAL5ZJQ49$N8=>u(B ($BFC=8(B $B?^=q4[L\O?$NAL5ZJQ49(B)$B!W!X>pJs$N2J3X$H5;=Q!Y(B42(3), p.198-203 (1992.3)
• $BJFED@/L@(B, $BD9C+Gn9T!V(B$BAL5ZJQ49$N?75;=Q(B ($BFC=8(B $B?^=q4[L\O?$NAL5ZJQ49(B)$B!W!X>pJs$N2J3X$H5;=Q!Y(B42(3), p.204-210 (1992.3)
• $BKL9n0l!V(B$B%*%s%i%$%s<+F0EPO?J}<0$K$h$kAL5ZJQ49(B : $B=q;o%f!<%F%#%j%F%#(BNACSIS-CAT$B$rMxMQ$7$F(B ($BFC=8(B $B?^=q4[L\O?$NAL5ZJQ49(B)$B!W!X>pJs$N2J3X$H5;=Q!Y(B42(3), p.211-218 (1992.3)
• $B@1Ln2m1Q!V(B$BAL5ZJQ49$HAm9gL\O?%G!<%?%Y!<%9(B ($BFC=8(B $B?^=q4[L\O?$NAL5ZJQ49(B)$B!W!X>pJs$N2J3X$H5;=Q!Y(B42(3), p.219-228 (1992.3)
• $B;3K\$+$*$k!V(B$BBg3X?^=q4[$K$*$1$kAL5ZJQ49(B : $BN)L?4[Bg3X$N>l9g(B ($BFC=8(B $B?^=q4[L\O?$NAL5ZJQ49(B)$B!W!X>pJs$N2J3X$H5;=Q!Y(B42(3), p.229-235 (1992.3)
• $B:4F#985W!V(B$BEl5~ETN)Bg3XIUB0?^=q4[$K$*$1$kAL5ZF~NO(B ($BFC=8(B $B?^=q4[L\O?$NAL5ZJQ49(B)$B!W!X>pJs$N2J3X$H5;=Q!Y(B42(3), p.236-242 (1992.3)
• $B3*@%CR90(B, $BF=H*LT;K!V(B$BBg5,LOAL5ZF~NO$N8=>l:n6H(B ($BFC=8(B $B?^=q4[L\O?$NAL5ZJQ49(B)$B!W!X>pJs$N2J3X$H5;=Q!Y(B42(3), p.243-250 (1992.3)

$BD,EDK|5]!V%G!<%?AL5ZF~NO$N30It0QBw(B : $BKLN$Bg3X65M\?^=q4[$N;vNc!W!XKLN$Bg3X0lHL650i5*MW!Y(B10, p.129-140 (2005)

$B9CHe=EIp!V(B$B7'K\Bg3X$K$*$1$k%+!<%IL\O?$K$h$kAL5ZF~NO(B$B!W!X(B$B6e=#CO6hBg3X?^=q4[6(5D2q;o(B$B!YBh(B39$B9f(B (1996)

$B9CHe=EIp(B, $B?92$BF|K\?^=q4[>pJs3X2q(B$B8&5f0Q0w2q(B($BJT(B)$B!X(B$BEE;R?^=q4[(B : $B%G%8%?%k>pJs$NN.DL$H?^=q4[$NL$Mh!YJY@?=PHG(B, 2001.11.10 ($B%7%j!<%:!&?^=q4[>pJs3X$N%U%m%s%F%#%"(B ; No.1), p.175-196

$B>.;37{;J(B, $B=)7n<"(B, $BK-EDM5>MSWord | PowerPoint$B!K(B
$BJ?@.(B14$BG/EY(B$BAm9gL\O?%G!<%?%Y!<%98&=$(B ($B9qN)>pJs3X8&5f=j(B) $BBh#12sL\O?C4Ev $B%0%k!<%WF$5D(B C$BHI(B 2002.10.31

$B?yK\>;I'!V>eCRBg3X?^=q4[$K$*$1$k(BNACSIS-CAT$B$NMxMQ$H%*%s%i%$%sAL5ZF~NO(B : $BOB=qAL5ZF~NO$rCf?4$H$7$F!W!XBg3X?^=q4[8&5f!Y(B38, p.80-90 (1991.10)

$BC]FbHfO$Li(B, $B@P0fJ]W"(B, $BC+_7<"@8!V%*%s%i%$%s%"%C%W%m!<%I5!G=$rMQ$$$?L\O?>pJsAL5ZF~NO(B : $BEl5~Bg3XImB0?^=q4[$K$*$1$k;n9T!W!XBg3X?^=q4[8&5f!Y(B36, p.28-36 (1990.7)

$Bm|><p%;%s%?!<%U%!%$%k$rMxMQ$7$F$NL\O?%+!<%I$K$h$k%*%s%i%$%sF~NO!W!XBg3X?^=q4[8&5f!Y(B34, p.49-61 (1989.6)

$BCfB<5A?M!V(B$BAL5ZF~NO$N8=>u$H:#8e$N7W2h(B$B!W!X$U$_$/$i(B: $BAa0pEDBg3X?^=q4[Js!Y(BNo.25, p.3 (1990.10.15)

$BA}ED85(B, $B9b66EX(B, $BJF_7@?(B, $BB$BFn=SO/!V(B$B?^=qL\O?%+!<%I8!:w%7%9%F%`$N3+H/$H2DG=@-(B : $B?^=q4[>pJs$N%P%i%s%9$N$H$l$?EE;R2=$rL\;X$7$F(B$B!W!X(BAcademic resource guide$B!Y(BNo.116$B!J(B2001.11.27$B!K(B

$BFn=SO/(B, $B7*ED1QOB(B, $BM-@n@aIW!V%$%a!<%8$K$h$k?^=qL\O?%+!<%I8!:w%7%9%F%`(B : $BAL5ZF~NOLdBj$N0l2r7hK!!W!X>pJs=hM}3X2q8&5fJs9p!Y(B2000(91), p.63-71 [2000.9.27]

$BFn=SO/(B, $B7*ED1QOB(B, $BM-@n@aIW!V(B$B%$%a!<%8$K$h$k?^=qL\O?%+!<%I8!:w%7%9%F%`(B : $BAL5ZF~NOLdBj$N0l2r7hK!!W!X%G%#%8%?%k?^=q4[!Y(BNo.18, p.27-35 (2000.9)
$B!V%G%#%8%?%k?^=q4[!W%o!<%/%7%g%C%W(B $BBh(B18$B2s(B ($B?^=q4[>pJsBg3X(B. 2000$BG/(B9$B7n(B27$BF|(B) $BH/I=O@J8(B

$BO;K\2BJ?(B($BJTCx(B)$B!XJF9q$NBg3X?^=q4[Ey;k;!Js9p=q(B : $B?^=q4[$NEE;R2=$rCf?4$K!YEl5~(B : $BEl5~Bg3XImB0?^=q4[(B, 1998.8

$B9qN)Bg3X?^=q4[6(2q(B $B?^=q4[>pJs%7%9%F%`FCJL0Q0w2qL\O?6HL3%7%9%F%`@lLg0Q0w2q:G=*Js9p(B$B!JJ?@.#8G/#77n!K(B, $B#3!%2~A1$9$Y$-;v9`$K$D$$$F(B

$B3X=Q?35D2q!X(B$BBg3X?^=q4[$K$*$1$kEE;R?^=q4[E*5!G=$N=<$B!Y3X=Q?35D2q(B, 1996.7

$B!V#3!%!!EE;R?^=q4[E*5!G=$N@0Hw$NJ}:v(B
   $B!J#1!K;qNA$NEE;R2=$N?d?J(B

$B#1!KL\O?>pJs$NAL5ZF~NO$NB%?J(B

   $B8=:_!$A49q$NBg3X?^=q4[$K$OLs#22/:}$N?^=q$,=jB"$5$l$F$$$k$,!$$3$N$&$AL\O?=j:_>pJs$,3X=Q>pJs%;%s%?!<$N%G!<%?%Y!<%9$K=8@Q$5$l$F$$$k$N$OLs#13dDxEY$G$"$k!#L\O?=j:_>pJs$O!$=jB";qNA$NEE;R2=$N$?$a$N4pAC$H$J$k$b$N$G$"$j!$$7$?$,$C$F!$L\O?=j:_>pJs$NAL5ZF~NO$O$5$i$KB%?J$5$l$k$Y$-$G$"$k!#!W(B

$BEl2mIW(B($BJT(B)$B!X(B$BI4J*8l2xCL2q(B$B!YEl5~(B : $BC^K`=qK<(B, 2007.7 ($B$A$/$^J88K(B ; [$B$U(B-36-5] . $BJ89k2xCL7f:nA*(B / $BEl2mIWJT(B ; $BFCJLJS(B)

$BKYEDN6Li!&1vC+5~;R(B($BJT(B)$B!X(B$B3X9;?^=q4[$G0i$`>pJs%j%F%i%7!<(B : $B$9$0.3X9;$N>pJs3hMQ%9%-%k!Y(B$BA49q3X9;?^=q4[6(5D2q(B, 2007

$B!V%[%s%H$N?M8}$O2??M$J$N!*!)(B : $B1vC+5~;R(B$B@h@8$N>pJs650i!W(B2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B16$BF|(B($BF|(B) 19:00-19:30 NHK $B650i%F%l%S(B; $B:FJ|Aw(B: 2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B19$BF|(B($B?e(B) 03:05-03:35 NHK BS2, 2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B22$BF|(B($BEZ(B) 01:05-01:35 NHK$B650i%F%l%S!X$o$/$o$/$B!VL\$HL\!WB@EDM5H~!"Bt0f0l7C!"(BAYUO($B9b660>@8(B)

($B=i@$(B)$B5\2<=(QX!V(B$BIw2VL58B(B$B!W(B-->

$B!V:#F|$O0lF|!Hd86J!I;0Kf!W(B2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B17$BF|(B($B7n(B) 9:20-11:50, 12:15-18:50 NHK FM

$B2.Ln90G7!XE/3X$N86Iw7J(B : $B8EBe%.%j%7%"$NCN7C$H$3$H$P!YEl5~(B : $BF|K\J|Aw=PHG6(2q(B, 1999.11 (NHK$B%i%$%V%i%j!<(B ; 106)

Diels, Hermann.  Die Fragmente der Vorsokratiker, griechisch und deutsch.  6. verb. Aufl. hrsg. von Walther Kranz.  Berlin : Weidmann, 1951-1952. $BFb;3>!Mx(B [$B$[$+(B]$BLu!X%=%/%i%F%90JA0E/3XH.$B%G%#!<%k%9!\(BW.$B%/%i%s%DJTLu(B $B!X%=%/%i%F%90JA0E/3X ($BE/3X$N7`>l(B)

$BH,1@=P!VGc=q$K$^$D$o$k%(%H!&%;%H%i!W(B$B!JA0JS!K(B07/25/1998, $B!J8eJS!K(B07/26/1998

$B!V(B$B$+$b$a?)F2(B$B!W(B2006$BG/!"2.>eD>;R4FFD!"72$h$&$386:n(B. 2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B18$BF|(B($B2P(B) 01:47-03:50 $BF|K\%F%l%S!X7nMK1G2h!Y(B

$BI\@n=$BBgF|K\%9%/%j!<%s@=B$(B, [2005.12.2].
($BBh(B1$B2s(B)$B!V8E3h;zHG,F/$BKkKv!W(B(html [1]-[26] | PDF p001$B!A(B023, p024$B!A(B046, p047$B!A(B081)
($B%?%$%]%0%i%U%#$N@$3&(B. $BAHHGJT(B ($B@iET%U%)%s%H%i%$%V%i%j!<(B))

$B9bLZ85!V(B$BFIK\$N=q;o$r$a$0$C$F(B$B!W!Xl&K\8&5f!YBh(B4$B=4>eEe(B, p.142-156 (1990.6$B!K(B

$B9bLZ85(B$B!X(B$B9>8MFIK\$N8&5f(B : $B==6e@$5*>.@bMM<0Z?!YEl5~(B : $B$Z$j$+$s$B9bLZ85(B$B!V(B$B8&5f ($BFC=8(B $B3X=Q>pJs%j%]%8%H%j(B)$B!W!X>pJs$N2J3X$H5;=Q!Y(B55(10), p.$B4,Kv(B1-$B4,Kv(B4 (2005.10.1)

$BCfB<9,I'!V(B$BIU(B $B?7$7$$?^=q4[0w!W!XCfB<9,I'Cx=R=8!YBh(B14$B4,!V=q;of\CL!W(B. $BEl5~(B : $BCf1{8xO@ $B!VC1$J$kL\O?$G$J$/!"=iHG=i:~!"8e:~!":FHG!"0[HG!"JdHG!"2~cbK\!"2~BjK\$J$IH9g$9$l$P$o$+$k$h$&$K$9$k!#$=$l$>$l$NK\$N=j:_!"B($A2?$H$$$&K\$N=iHG=i:~$,!"2?=h$K$"$C$F!"$=$N=iHG=i:~$J$k$3$H$r>Z$9$kFCD'$O$3$3$K$"$k!#2~HG8e:~$OKt2?4[$NB"=q$G!"=iHG=i:~$H$O2?=h$,0c$C$F$$$k$+$J$I$rCm5-$9$k$N$G$"$k!#0l?M0l?M$,0l$D0l$D$NK\$K$h$C$FH/8+$9$k$J$I$$$&8=>u$rAa$/C&=P$5$;$M$P$J$i$J$$$,!"$+$+$kL\O?$N:n@.$b!"3X3&$K$^$+$;$F$*$1$P!"2?;~=PMh$k$+$o$+$i$J$$!#!W(B (p.480)

$B%8%c%s!&%7%Y%j%&%9(B$B!J(BJean Sibelius, 1865$BG/(B12$B7n(B8$BF|(B - 1957$BG/(B9$B7n(B20$BF|!KKW8e(B50$B<~G/(B

$B!X%_%e!<%8%C%/%W%i%6(B. $BBh#1It(B $B%/%i%7%C%/!Y(B 2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B20$BF|(B($BLZ(B) 14:00-16:00 NHK FM; $B:FJ|Aw(B: 2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B21$BF|(B($B6b(B) 07:20-09:17 NHK FM

$B!V!HHa$7$$%o%k%D!I:nIJ#4#4$N#1!W!!!!!!!!!!!!!!%7%Y%j%&%9:n6J(B
$B!J2~D{HG!"1iAU2qMQ%t%!!<%8%g%s!K(B
$B!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!J#5J,#1#6IC!K(B
$B!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!J4I893Z!K%i%O%F%#8r6A3ZCD(B
$B!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!J;X4x!K%*%9%b!&%t%!%s%9%+(B
$B!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!c#B#I#S!!#K#K#C#C!]#2#2#5#6!d(B

$B!VAH6J!H%+%l%j%"!I:nIJ#1#1!W!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!%7%Y%j%&%9:n6J(B
$B!!!!!&4VAU6J!!!&%P%i!<%I!!!&9T?J6JIw$K(B
$B!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!J#1#6J,#1#5IC!K(B
$B!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!J4I893Z!K%"%+%G%_!<<
$B!X$T$"$N%T%"!Y7nMK!A6bMK(B 07:35-07:45 NHK BShi; 
$B:FJ|Aw(B: $B7nMK!A6bMK(B 18:45-18:55 NHK BS2, $B7nMK!A6bMK(B 21:50-22:00 NHK BShi, 
$BF|MK(B($B#1=54V$^$H$a$F:FJ|Aw(B) 06:00-06:50 NHK BShi


$BBh(B179$B2s!V%U%#%s%i%s%I$r8+$D$a$F!!%7%Y%j%&%9!W(B2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B20$BF|(B($BLZ(B)

5$B$D$N>.IJ!!:nIJ(B75($B%8%c%s!&%7%Y%j%&%9(B) $B1iAU!'EDIt5~;R(B ; 
$B%$%s%?%S%e!<=P1i(B: $BC+;39@;R(B($B%7%s%,!<%=%s%0%i%$%?!<(B)
$BBh(B180$B2s!V5p>"$r;Y$($?2HB20&!W(B2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B21$BF|(B($B6b(B)

5$B$D$N>.IJ!!:nIJ(B85($B%8%c%s!&%7%Y%j%&%9(B) $B1iAU!'EDIt5~;R(B ; 
$B%$%s%?%S%e!<=P1i(B: $B5H>>N4(B($B:n6J2H(B)


$B1J9>O/!XITNI$N$?$a$NFI=q=Q!YEl5~(B : $BC^K`=qK<(B, 1997.5.25. $B@$EDC+6hN)1|Bt?^=q4[(B. 2002$BG/(B2$B7n(B3$BF|(B($BF|(B)
$B1J9>O/!XITNI$N$?$a$NFI=q=Q!YEl5~(B : $BC^K`=qK<(B, 2000.5.10 ($B$A$/$^J88K(B). $BL\9u6hN)NP$,5V?^=q4[(B. 2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B22$BF|(B($BEZ(B)

$B!V(B            
$B@~$J$I0z$+$:!"$,$s$,$sFI$a(B




  $B1&$B!V@h@8$O$M(B ($B$3$&$$$&650w$K8B$C$F!"<+J,$N$3$H$r@h@8$HJ?5$$G8F$V(B)$B!"K\$rFI$`$H$-!"$+$J$i$:@V1tI.$r;}$D$h$&$K$7$F$k$s$@!#=EMW$@$H;W$&2U=j$d%O%C$H$5$;$i$l$kJ8>O$K=P2q$C$?$i!"K5@~$r=q$-9~$`$s$@$h!#@~$r0z$$$F$$$k$H!"$=$NItJ,$,5[<}$G$-$k$h$&$J46$8$,$9$k!#K\$rFI$_=*$o$C$F$+$i%Q%i%Q%i$H%Z!<%8$r$a$/$k$H!"@~$r0z$$$?$H$3$m$@$1$,L\$KHt$S9~$s$G$/$k!W(B

  $B$?$V$s4dGH?7=q$N!X;d$NFI=qK!!Y$K$"$k>>EDF;M:$N%(%C%;%$$N($BB@$/$F=@$i$+$$;f4,$-?'1tI.$@(B) $B$K8B$k$H$+$J$s$H$+(B$Bi>C_(B($B$&$s$A$/(B)$B$rF@0U5$$K8l$C$?$j$7$F!#=c??$@$C$?$\$/$O!"$3$l$rJ9$$$?$H$-%[%[%&$H46?4$7$?$b$N$@(B ($B$<$R<+J,$b$=$N%@!<%^%H$J$s$H$+$r $B!#$$$^$J$i!V%P%C%+$8$c$M$'$N!W$H8@$&$s$@$1$I!#(B


  $B@V1tI.$r;}$?$L$^$G$b!"=q$$$F$"$k$3$H$r;D$i$:5[<}$7$F$d$m$&$H!"0U5$9~$`?M$b$$$k!#L\C$(5n$k$Y$-$b$N$O>C$(5n$k!#$=$l$G$$$$$8$c$J$$$+!#@V@~0z$3$&$H9u@~0z$3$&$H!"$"$k$$$OMn=q$-$d%a%b$r$7$h$&$H$=$N?M$N>!

$B4#0BK>!X@$3&$N9q4z?^4U(B : $BNr;K$H$H$b$K?J2=$9$k9q4z!YEl5~(B : $BPs@.$B8MED$d$9$7(B($B4k2h!&JT=8(B)$B!X(B$B9q4z$N$($[$s(B : $B%"%$%&%(%*=g!Y8MED%G%6%$%s8&5f<<(B, 1987.7
$B%U%i%C%0!&%$%s%9%F%#%A%e!<%HJTCx!X(B$B@$3&$N9q4z(B : $B9q>O!&=#4z!&9q:]5!4X4z!YEl5~(B : $B?7
$BF|9bIRN4!X(B$BF0J*$H?M4V$N@$3&G'<1(B : $B%$%j%e!<%8%g%s$J$7$K@$3&$O8+$($J$$!YEl5~(B : $BC^K`=qK<(B, 2003.12


$BF|9bIRN4!XF0J*$H?M4V$N@$3&G'<1(B : $B%$%j%e!<%8%g%s$J$7$K@$3&$O8+$($J$$!YEl5~(B : $BC^K`=qK<(B, 2007 ($B$A$/$^3X7]J88K(B ; $B%R(B 11-1)

$B;3K\?.5H!X8EE5@R$,8l$k(B : $B=qJ*$NJ82=;K!YEl5~(B : $BH,LZ=qE9(B, 2004.11$B!Z(B0200:406$B![(B


$BAa0pEDBg3X?^=q4[(B WEB$BE8Mw2q(B

No.42 $B0[7A$N$b$N$?$A(B - $BME2x$H$*2=$1$N@$3&(B -
No.43 $B0[7A$N$b$N$?$A(B - $BME2x$H$*2=$1$N@$3&(B -($BB3(B)

[$BEm2V1`;0@iK{(B($BCx(B)] ; $BC]86=U@t(B [$B2h(B] ; [$B1[8e7I;R(B($BK]9o!&8=Be8lLu(B)]$B!X(B$BEm;3?MLkOC(B : $B3(K\I4J*8l!YEl5~(B : $B3Q@n=qE9(B, 2006.7.25 ($B3Q@nJ88K(B ; 14329 . $B3Q@n%=%U%#%"J88K(B ; 335). 705$B1_!\>CHq@G(B5%. $BITFs20=qE9(B($B<+M3$,5V(B). 2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B22$BF|(B($BEZ(B)-2009$BG/(B12$B7n(B8$BF|(B($B2P(B)


$B:4F#0!5*(B$B!X(B$BE7;H(B$B!YEl5~(B : $BJ8i:=U=)(B, 2002.11

$B:4F#0!5*!XE7;H!YEl5~(B : $BJ8i:=U=)(B, 2005.1.10 ($BJ8=UJ88K(B ; [$B$5(B-32-3]). 590$B1_!\>CHq@G(B5%. $B@D;3%V%C%/%;%s%?!<(B($B<+M3$,5VE9(B). 2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B23$BF|(B($BF|(B)-10$B7n(B2$BF|(B($B2P(B)
$B:4F#0!5*(B$B!X(B$B1@?}(B$B!YEl5~(B : $BJ8i:=U=)(B, 2004.3

$B:4F#0!5*!X1@?}!YEl5~(B : $BJ8i:=U=)(B, 2007.5.10 ($BJ8=UJ88K(B ; [$B$5(B-32-4]). 571$B1_!\>CHq@G(B5%. $BITFs20=qE9(B($B<+M3$,5V(B). 2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B22$BF|(B($BEZ(B)-12$B7n(B12$BF|(B($B?e(B)
$B:4F#E/Li(B 

>  $B"#(B $BK\C*$N0l3Q(B > $B!XE7;H!Y!X1@?}!Y(B / $B:4F#0!5*!JJ8i:=U=)(B,2002/10,2004/3$B!K(B

$BCS_72F$BD)H/$9$k=qJ*$r$I$&FI$`$+(B$B!W!XIw$,%Z!<%8$r!E!E!YEl5~(B : $BJ8i:=U=)(B, 2003.11.30 ($BCS_72F
$B!V(B  $B:4F#0!5*$N!X(B$BE7;H(B$B!Y!JJ8i:=U=)!!0l<70l;M1_!\@G!K$H$$$&>.@b$r3Z$7$s$@!#Bh0l.@b!#  $B?M$NF,$NCf$K$"$k;W9M$rFI$s$@$j!"YxMp$7$?$j!";~$K$OF,$=$N$b$N$r2u$7$?$j$9$kG=NO$@!#$3$l$K$b?M$4$H$K6/  $B$3$N@_Dj$O!XE7;H!Y$K$H$C$FBg;v$@$,!"$7$+$7$=$l$,$9$Y$F$G$O$J$$!#Bg=0>.@b$K;EN)$F$k$H$7$?$i!":n  $B$@$,!"$3$N>.@b$NJ8BN$O6KEY$K6XM_E*$G!"B?$/$N>JN,$KIY$_!J!V>JN,$KIY$`!W$H$$$&$N$OF5Ce8lK!$@$m$&$+!)!K!"$^$5$K$=$3$,FI  $B$3$N$"$?$j$O1G2h$rNc$K0z$$$?J}$,$o$+$j$d$9$$$+$b$7$l$J$$!#:#$N%O%j%&%C%I1G2h$O%G%8%?%k5;=Q$r6n;H$7$F2?$+$i2?$^$G4Q5R$K8+$;$k!#$"$k$$$O$9$Y$F$r8+$?5$$K$5$;$k!#$7$+$7!"$?$H$($P%I%$%DI=8=HL@$NCf$G$*$\$m$K8+$kJ}$,A[A|NO$NF/$/M>CO$,A}$($k!#$3$N>.@b$NJ8BN$b$^$?$=$&$$$&0UL#$G$NFI  $B$b$&0l$D$O!"$3$l$3$=Nr;K>.@b$NI,?\$N>r7o$@$,!"J*8l$HeN.3,5i$N?M!9$,GO$l$r$I$&8+$F$$$?$+!"$H$$$&$h$&$J$H$3$m$,$$$$$N$@!#(B

  $B4N?4$ND6G=NO$r6n;H$7$?@o$$$N>lLL$G!"$\$/$O%&%#%j%"%`!&%.%V%9%s$N!X%K%e!<%m%^%s%5!pJs$rEp$`$?$a$K@xF~$9$k4VD5$J$$$7%(!<%8%'%s%H$H$$$&E@$G$O%8%'%k%8%e$b%1%$%9$bJQ$o$i$J$$!#GX8e$K$"$k5pBg$J@*NO$H$7$F0lJ}$K$O%O%W%9%V%k%02H$,$"$j!"B>J}$K$O%F%9%#%(!a%"%7%e%W!<%k2H$,$"$k!#;mE*$J9bL)EY$NJ8BN$b!"G>Fb6u4V$G$N@o$$$b!"$h$/;w$F$$$k!#(B

  $B1|9T$-$,$"$k$N$KF~8}$,COL#$JK\$r>R2p$9$k$N$O=qI>$B=i=P!'!X=54)J8=U!Y!V;d$NFI=qF|5-!W=i=PG/7nF|!'#2#0#0#3G/#17n#1#6F|(B


$BLZItE0!V(B2005$BG/(B2$B7n(B21$BF|!J7n!K$NB3$-(B$B!W!J(B$B$[$\F|4);qNAJ]B8(B$B!K(B
$B!V(B$B!V5.=E;qNA$OGr$NLJ$B!W!J(B$B$[$\F|4);qNAJ]B8(B ; 2005$BG/(B12$B7n(B22$BF|!JLZ!K!K(B

$B!X8=Be$N?^=q4[!Y$N>.FC=8!V?^=q4[;qNA$N1xGKB;(B--$BMxMQ$B$[$\F|4);qNAJ]B8(B ;  2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B13$BF|!JLZ!K(B)

            
2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B13$BF|!JLZ!K(B
            
$B!X8=Be$N?^=q4[!Y$N>.FC=8!V?^=q4[;qNA$N1xGKB;(B--$BMxMQ
            $B;(;o!X8=Be$N?^=q4[!Y!J(BVol.45, No.2, 2007.6$B!K$O>.FC=8$H$7$F!V?^=q4[;qNA$N1xGKB;(B--$BMxMQ
            

            $B>.FC=8$K$"$?$C$F!!?\1JOBG7!!(B--55


            


            $B1xGKB;$rIT2w$K;W$&MxMQ

            $BMxMQl$+$i9M$($??^=q4[;qNA$N1xGKB;LdBj$X$NDs8@!#Aa5^$JHo32>u67$NGD0.$H6&$KMxMQ
            

            $B?^=q4[$N%b%i%k$r@8$-1d$S$kF;$rF;$r65$($h(B--$B?7J9Ej=q$K8+$k?^=q$N=q$-9~$_!&@Z$j.@tE0!!(B--64

            $BD+F|?7J9!&FIGd?7J9$NEj=qMs$+$i?^=q4[$K4X$9$k$b$N$rCj=P$7!"(B1991$BG/$K3+$+$l$??^=q4[Bg2q;qNAJ]B8J,2J2q$G$N%"%s%1!<%HD4::$+$i$$$/$D$+$NBP:v0F$rDs<(!"%"%a%j%+$H%$%.%j%9$G$NBP:v$b>R2p$7$F$$$k!#(B


            


            $B?^=q4[;qNA$N1xGKB;$HL5CG;}$A=P$7$K$D$$$F!!!!;38}M3H~!!(B--74

            $BHo32$rR2p!#8x6&?^=q4[$G$NHo32$N
            

            $B%8%g!<%8!&%*!<%H%s(B--$BK\$X$N967b!?;R!!(B--80

            $B?^=q4[$+$i?^=q$rEp$s$@$j1xGKB;$5$;7:L3=j$K#6%v7nEj9v$5$l$?%$%.%j%9$N7`:n2H%*!<%H%s$K$D$$$F!#7:4|8e$K

 	
$B>.FC=8!V?^=q4[;qNA$N1xGKB;(B : $BMxMQ
$B?\1JOBG7!V>.FC=8$K$"$?$C$F(B ($B>.FC=8(B $B?^=q4[;qNA$N1xGKB;(B : $BMxMQ$B=t669'0l!V1xGKB;$rIT2w$K;W$&MxMQ.FC=8(B $B?^=q4[;qNA$N1xGKB;(B : $BMxMQ$B>.@tE0!V?^=q4[$N%b%i%k$r@8$-1d$S$kF;$rF;$r65$($h(B : $B?7J9Ej=q$K8+$k?^=q$N=q$-9~$_!&@Z$j.FC=8(B $B?^=q4[;qNA$N1xGKB;(B : $BMxMQ$B;38}M3H~!V?^=q4[;qNA$N1xGKB;$HL5CG;}$A=P$7$K$D$$$F(B ($B>.FC=8(B $B?^=q4[;qNA$N1xGKB;(B : $BMxMQ$BLpEgD>;R!V%8%g!<%8!&%*!<%H%s(B : $BK\$X$N967b!?.FC=8(B $B?^=q4[;qNA$N1xGKB;(B : $BMxMQ

$B5\2vOBCK!V(B$B%m%7%d@NOC$NOC7?L\O?JT=8$r$a$0$C$F(B ($B8&5f%N!<%H(B)$B!W!X%9%i%t8&5f!Y(B39, p.223-246 (1992)
$BW"Dm4p2p(B, $BD9M'@iBe<#!XF|K\=q;o3X$r3X$V?M$N$?$a$K!Y5~ET(B : $B@$3&;WA[
$B!V(B  $BF|K\?M$N:n$C$?4A;m!"4AJ8$NK\$O!"4A@R$H$O8+$J$$!#F|K\?M$N:n$C$?4A;m!"4AJ8$OF|K\8l$G9M$(!":n;m!&:nJ8$7$F$+$i!"$=$l$r4AJ8$i$7$/8l$N=g$r49$($k$b$N$G!"K\Mh$O4A;z$G=q$$$?F|K\J83X$G$"$k!#$@$+$iAw$j2>L>!"JV$jE@$J$I$rIU$1$FF|K\8l$H$7$FFI$`!#Cf9q8l$H$7$FFI$^$J$$$+$i=`4A@R$K$bF~$l$J$$!#!W(B(p.138)






$BF|K\$NFI$_J}(B ($B2;Lu$NIt20(B)
$B!V$J$<=w$N;R$O%9%+!<%H!)!W!XD+F|?7J9!Y(B2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B24$BF|(B($B7n(B) $BD+4)(B, p.27 ($B5?Ld2r7h(B $B%b%s%8%m!<(B)
$B!VIt20$N@0M}$,4V$K9g$o$:!"%i%s%A2qCf;_!W!XD+F|?7J9!Y(B2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B24$BF|(B($B7n(B) $BD+4)(B, p.27 ($B$"$J$?$N0B?4(B . $B$*JR$E$1$N%R%s%H(B ; 1)
$B!V@0M}$N#83d$O$B%O%&%9%-!<%T%s%06(2q(B $B5HB$B!V$B%O%&%9%-!<%T%s%06(2q(B $B5HB$B!VJ]B8$NCN7C$G5M$a$9$.2r>C!W!XD+F|?7J9!Y(B2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B27$BF|(B($BLZ(B) $BD+4)(B, p.31 ($B$"$J$?$N0B?4(B . $B$*JR$E$1$N%R%s%H(B ; 4) $B?)J82=8&5f2H(B $B5{JA?NG7=u(B
$B!VM}A[9b$9$.!)%"%k%P%`:n$j!W!XD+F|?7J9!Y(B2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B28$BF|(B($B6b(B) $BD+4)(B, p.29 ($B$"$J$?$N0B?4(B . $B$*JR$E$1$N%R%s%H(B ; 5) $BIY;N%U%$%k%`%$%a!<%8%s%0(B $B%7%K%"%^%M!<%8%c!<(B $BC*66?J(B
$B!VIW$N$$$L4V$K6H$B%"!<%H0z1[%;%s%?!<(B $B%i%$%U%5%]!<%H;v6HIt%^%M%8%c!<(B $B0KF#Gn(B
$B!V%8%g%K!<$O@o>l$X9T$C$?!W(BJohnny got his gun. 1971$BG/!"%"%a%j%+!"%@%k%H%s!&%H%i%s%\(B(Dalton Trumbo)$B4FFD(B. 2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B27$BF|(B($BLZ(B) 01:00-02:55 NHK BS2$B!X1R@11G2h7`>l!Y(B

$B@6?eNIE5!X(B2$B=54V$G>.@b$r=q$/!*(B$B!YEl5~(B : $B88E_$B!V.@b!W(B2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B27$BF|(B($BLZ(B) 19:30-19:56 NHK$BAm9g%F%l%S(B; $B:FJ|Aw(B: 20:32-20:58 NHK BS2$B!X%/%m!<%:%"%C%W8=Be!Y(B(No.2468)$B9qC+M5;R(B ; $B%9%?%8%*%2%9%H(B: $B@6?eNIE5(B$B$5$s!JJ87]I>O@2H!K(B


$B1v@n?-L@(B$B!V(B$B%+!<%k!&#R!&%]%Q!$B!W!J0l6e6e<7G/0l!;7n!K(B$BFI=q%N!<%H(B
Popper, Karl R. The poverty of historicism.  London : Routledge & Kegan Paul, c1957

$B%+!<%k!&(BR. $B%]%Q!$B;T0f;0O:!XNr;K$N?JJb$H$O$J$K$+!YEl5~(B : $B4dGH=qE9(B, 1971.10 ($B4dGH?7=q(B ; $B@D(B-800)
$B!!(B 

$B1:BtD>21$B@$5*>/G/(B$B!Y(B[20$B@$5*>/G/(B $B:G=*>O(B]($B2<(B). $B>.3X4[(B, 2007.10.3 [9$B7n(B28$BF|(B($B6b(B)$BH/Gd(B] ($B%S%C%0(B $B%3%_%C%/%9(B). 524$B1_!\>CHq@G(B5%. $BITFs20=qE9(B($B<+M3$,5V(B). 2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B28$BF|(B($B6b(B)

$B@n86@t!X%l%J!<%I8=>]$K$OM}M3$,$"$k!YGr@tCHq@G(B5%. $BEl5^%9%H%"(B($B<+M3$,5VE9(B). 2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B28$BF|(B($B6b(B)


$BCSC+0K:4IW!X=qJ*$NC#?M!YEl5~(B : $BEl5~=q@R(B, 2000.9.7. $BL\9u6hN)NP$,5V?^=q4[(B. 2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B29$BF|(B($BEZ(B)
$BNkLZ=S9,!X9>8M$NFI=qG.(B : $B<+3X$9$kFI

$B;MJ}ED8$I'!X?M4V$r
Koeber, Raphael. $B5WJ]JY(B($BLuJT(B)$B!X%1!<%Y%kGn;N?oI.=8!YBh(B22$B:~2~HG(B. $BEl5~(B : $B4dGH=qE9(B, 1957.11.25 ($B4dGHJ88K(B ; $B@D(B641-1). $BL\9u6hN)NP$,5V?^=q4[(B. 2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B29$BF|(B($BEZ(B)

$B!V(B$B`t;v(B($B$5$8(B)$B$K(B$B94E%(B($B$3$&$G$$(B)$B$9$k>.3X9;65;U(B$B=-(B($B$/$5(B)$B$$K5Cp!L(B$BFICp(B$B!M$r$b$C$F1x$5$l$F$$$k$+$H$$$&$3$H$=$NB>$N$h$&$J!#(B
... $B!#$3$l$i$O$=$N=qJ*$r$P2f$i$K$H$C$F0&$9$Y$/(B$B5.(B($B$H$&$H(B)$B$V$Y$-$b$N$?$i$7$a$&$k$H$H$b$K!"$^$?0lEY8B$j$G$=$l$r(B$B7y1^(B($B$1$s$($s(B)$B$9$k$K;j$i$7$a$k$3$H$b$G$-$k!#H]!"$=$l$i$O(B$B1}!9(B($B$*$&!@!?(B)$B$K$7$F$^$5$7$/2f$i$N46>p$r32$7$?$j$^$?2f$i$rE\$i$;$?$j$9$k$3$H$b$"$jF@$k!"!=!=="Cf$+$NL5CQ$J$k!XHcI>E*!YK5Cp$d!"5?Ld$J$i$S$K4VEj;lId$J$I$O$=$N:G$b?S$@$7$-$b$N$G$"$k!#8|4i$J$kFI?M$N!"$B($B$+$j$@(B)$B$7$?=qJ*$r$9$i!=!=1}!9?'1tI.$r$b$C$F!=!=(B$B1x(B($B$1$,(B)$B$9$r>o$H$9$k$N$G$"$k!#0lBN=qJ*$r!"$7$+$b0NBg$J$kJ8?M$NCx:n$r$9$i$+$/$BlML1E*(B($B$;$s$_$s$F$-(B)$B=,47$O!"$3$l$R$H$jCx$BIn?+(B($B$V$8$g$/(B)$B$r2C$($k$b$N$H(B$B0b(B($B$$(B)$B$&$Y$-$G$"$k!#!W(B(p.140-141)


$B2FL\^{@P!V%1!<%Y%k@h@8!W(B ($B>.$5$J;qNA<<(B ; $B;qNA(B204)

2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B29$BF|(B($BEZ(B) 18:00-21:00 NHK FM$B!X#N6A1iAU2q!Y;3EDH~Li;R(B, $BEl>r@YIW(B

$B8r6A;m!V(B$B%F%#%k!&%*%$%l%s%7%e%T!<%2%k(B$B$NL{2w$J$$$?$:$i!W:nIJ(B28 ($B#R!&%7%e%H%i%&%9(B)
$B%P%$%*%j%s6(AU6JBh(B5$BHV%$D9D4(B K.219$B!V%H%k%3Iw!W(B ($B%b!<%D%!%k%H(B)
$B8r6A6JBh(B1$BHV%OC;D4(B $B:nIJ(B68 ($B%V%i!<%`%9(B)

$B%b!<%7%'!&%"%D%b%s;X4x!?#N#H#K8r6A3ZCD(B, $B%;%k%2%$!&%/%j!<%m%U(B($B%P%$%*%j%s(B)


(2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B29$BF|(B($BEZ(B) : $B#N#H#K%[!<%k(B : $BBh(B1601$B2s#N6ADj4|8x1i(B)

2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B29$BF|(B($BEZ(B) 21:00-22:00 NHK FM$B!XL>6J$N$?$N$7$_(B. $B;d$N;nD0<
$BL5H$B%S%*%i!&%=%J%?(B ($B%j%2%F%#(B)$B!J#2#3J,#1#6IC!K(B

$B%"%s%H%o!<%L!&%?%`%9%F%#!J%S%*%i!K(B
$B!V%+%j%V$N=w!&%f!<%^!W(B2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B29$BF|(B($BEZ(B) 22:00-22:50 NHK FM$B!X(BFM$B%7%"%?!$B86:n!'%i%U%+%G%#%*!&%O!<%s(B, $BLu!'J?@nM490(B, $B5S?'!'C+EP;VM:(B, $B2;3Z!'EDF,JY(B, $B1i=P!'J]2J5A5W(B
$B%i%U%+%G%#%*!&%O!<%sCx(B ; $BJ?@nM490Lu!X(B$B%+%j%V$N=w(B$B!YEl5~(B : $B2O=P=qK  $BFbMF(B: $B%A!<%?(B ; $B%f!<%^(B
  $BJL%?%$%H%k(B: Chita ; Youma

$BJ?0fDh0l(B$BLu!X(B$BA4Lu>.@tH,1@:nIJ=8(B$B!YBh(B4$B4,!VJ)NN@>%$%s%I$NFsG/4V(B($B>5A0(B) ; $B%A%?(B ; $B%f!<%^!WEl5~(B $B!'(B $B91J8, 1967.1
$BJ?0fDh0l!X??LkCf$N]#!YEl5~AO85CHq@G(B5% $B@D;3%V%C%/%;%s%?!<(B($B<+M3$,5VE9(B), 2000$BG/(B9$B7n(B17$BF|(B($BF|(B)$B!A(B10$B7n(B6$BF|(B($B6b(B)

$B!V$I$i$d$-$GM-L>$J>eLn$N!V(B$B$&$5$.$d(B$B!W$K$&$+$,$&$H!"@h@8$OBT$C$F$*$i$l!"$I$i$d$-$r$$$/$D$b%Q%/$D$-$J$,$iLkCY$/$^$GK0$+$:$K(B$B8E(B($B$U$k(B)$B$4$H$r$*OC$7$5$l$?!#$*$B!J9SKs9(!V=x!!J?Db@h@8$N;W$$$G!W$h$j(B p.11$B!K(B




$B!V(B ... $BDh0l$O@88e$^$b$J$/@82H$NC+8}2H$+$i!"El5~F|K\66IMD.$GC:20$r1D$`J?0f@/5H!&$9!6IW:J$NM\;R$K=P$5$l$?$N$G$"$k!#(B

$B!!$J$*!"AP;R$N7;$K$"$?$k(B$BC+8}4n:n(B$B$O!"$N$A$K>eLn$GOB2[;RE9!V$&$5$.$d!W$rAO6H!"@.8y$5$;$?>&:M$"$k?MJ*$@$,!"0lJ}$GDo$H$H$b$KGP6g$r(B$BG=(B($B$h(B)$B$/$9$k$B!JEl2mIW!V(BLonely Waters : $BJ?0fDh0l$H$=$N;~Be!W$h$j(B p.377$B!K(B

$B!X(B$BA4Lu>.@tH,1@:nIJ=8(B$B!YEl5~(B : $B91J8, 1964-1967. 12$B:}(B


$BBh(B1$B4,!V0u>]GI:n2HF|5->6(B ; $B%/%j!<%*!<%k>.IJ=8(B ; $BCf9q2xCL=8!W(B1965.11
$BBh(B2$B4,!VHt2VMnMU=8(B ; $B$-$^$0$lAp!W(B1965.4
$BBh(B3$B4,!V??2F$NG.BS9T(B ; $B%^%k%F%#%K!<%/>.IJ=8!W(B1966.3
$BBh(B4$B4,!VJ)NN@>%$%s%I$NFsG/4V(B($B>5A0(B) ; $B%A%?(B ; $B%f!<%^!W(B1967.1
$BBh(B5$B4,!VF|K\JM8+5-(B($B>e(B)$B!W(B1964.7
$BBh(B6$B4,!VF|K\JM8+5-(B($B2<(B)$B!W(B1964.8, 
$BBh(B7$B4,!VEl$N9q$+$i(B ; $B?4!W(B1964.9
$BBh(B8$B4,!VJ)$NH*$NMnJf(B ; $B0[9qIwJ*$H2sA[!W(B1964.10
$BBh(B9$B4,!VNn$NF|K\(B ; $BL@0E(B ; $BF|K\;(5-!W(B1964.12
$BBh(B10$B4,!V9|F!(B ; $B2xCL(B ; $BE7$N@ne:k}!W(B1964.6
$BBh(B11$B4,!VF|K\(B : $B0l$D$N;nO@!W(B1964.11
$BBh(B12$B4,!V;W$$=P$N5-(B / $B>.@t@a;RCx(B . $BIc!VH,1@!W$r21$&(B / $B>.@t0lM:Cx!W(B1967.4

$B!X(B$B%i%U%+%G%#%*!&%O!<%sCx:n=8(B$B!YEl5~(B : $B91J8, 1980-1988. 15$B:}(B


$B5~6K2FI'(B$B!XME2x$NM}ME2x$N]#!Y3Q@n=qE9(B, 2007.9.5 ($B2x(BBOOKS). 1,800$B1_!\>CHq@G(B5%. $B%V%C%/%U%!!<%9%H(B($B<+M3$,5VE9(B). 2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B30$BF|(B($BF|(B)-14$BF|(B($B?e(B)

$B$R$5$&$A$_$A$*!X(B$B@:#G(B : $BJl$H;R$Ne+!YEl5~(B : $B@DNS9)i:, 2007.9.25. 1,000$B1_!\>CHq@G(B5%. $B@D;3%V%C%/%;%s%?!<(B($B<+M3$,5VE9(B). 2007$BG/(B9$B7n(B30$BF|(B($BF|(B)

hicksian$B!V(B$BBg3X$O7zJ*$G$O$J$$(B$B!W(B 2006$BG/(B10$B7n(B2$BF|(B($B7n(B)
 (Irregular Economist$B!A%l%.%e%i!<@h@8$H(Bhicksian$B$N7P:Q3X3X=,D"!A(B)

$BEDCf=(?C!V(B$BBg3X$O7zJ*$G$O$J$$EA@b%j%?!<%s%:(B$B!W(B 2007-08-07


$B!V(B			
$B!!$$$^=q$$$F$kK\$+$i$NMn$AMU=&$$!#(B
			
$B!!0JA0$KOCBj$K$J$C$?%7%e%`%Z!<%?!<$,$$$C$?$H$5$l$k!VBg3X$O7zJ*$G$O$J$$!WEA@b!#$3$NOC$,0l66$NCf$G@bF@NO$r;}$C$?CNE*EZ>m$,%7%e%`%Z!<%?!<$NMhF|0JA0$+$i$"$C$?$N$G$O$J$$$+!#$H$$$&$N$,$3$N%(%s%H%j!<$N8fBj$G$9!#(B

			
$B;29M%V%m%0!J0l66Bg3X?^=q4[$5$s$b%3%a%s%H$r4s$;$F$^$9$M!K(B
			
http://hicksian.cocolog-nifty.com/irregular_economist/2006/10/post_0f59.html

			
$B!!$=$l$O0l66Bg3X$N7P:Q3X$NAD$H$$$($kJ!EDFA;0$,=q$$$?!VBg3X$H$O2?$>$d!W!JL@<#(B40$BG/!K$H$$$&%(%C%;%$!JF1BjL>$N$b$N$,J!ED$NA4=8$K$"$k$,$=$l$H$O0c$&!#F1$8l$b$J$/$F$h$7!"$*$=$m$$$NK9;R$K$D$1$k!V%a%s%3!W7A$N6bJR$b$J$/$F$h$m$7!"8fLr?M$b$$$J$/$F:9$7;Y$($J$7!"$H0J>e#4$D$N$b$N$r$"$2$F$$$k!#(B

			
$B!!$=$7$FJ!ED$OBg3X$O;\@_$G$O$J$$!"$HB>$NBg3XO@!JA4=8<}O?$N!VBg3X$H$O2?$>$d!W!VBg3X$NK\5A$HB6$N<+M3!W$J$I!K$G$b:F;0L@8@$7$F$$$?$N$G$"$k!#Bg3X$O;\@_$G$O$J$/!"$=$3$G8&5f$9$k3X

			
$B!!%7%e%`%Z!<%?!<$,MhF|$7$?>"$d28;U$N;W$$=P$K$D$J$,$k$H$7$?$i!D!D!VBg3X$O7zJ*$G$O$J$$!W$,EA@b$H$7$F:,IU$/CNE*$JEZ>m$K2C$($F!"0l66$N?M!9$K46>pE*$JLL$G$b%7%e%`%Z!<%?!<$NH/8@$K6&46$G$-$k$b$N$,$"$C$?$N$+$b$7$l$J$$!J$=$&9M$($k$H$3$NEA@b$O$5$i$K??

			
$B!!$J$*%7%e%`%Z!<%?!<$O!JJ!ED$NDo;R$G$b$"$j<+?H$NDo;R$G$b$"$C$?!KCf;30KCNO:$K%/!<%k%N!2A$7$?$H$$$&!#(B
$B!W(B



Carlyle, Thomas. Past and present.  London : Chapman and Hall, 1843


$BBh;M>O!V;:6H$NBbD9!W(B. Thomas Carlyle ; $B>eEDOBIWLu!X2a5n$H8=:_!YEl5~(B : $BF|K\65J8
$B!V(B  
$B;:6H$,;XF3$G$-$k$b$N$J$i$P!";:6H$N;XF3/$O<+M3$K$G$-$k8$$I$b!"$D$^$j%U%i%s%9?M$,$&$^$/!V(B$B2($B%+%J%$%f(B)$B!W$H$h$s$@$b$N$K$7$+$J$l$J$$$N$G$"$m$&$+!)!!;:6H$NBbD9$O!"??$N@o;N$G$"$k!"$3$l$+$i$OM#0l$N??$N@o;N$HG'$a$i$l$k$G$"$m$&!#:.FY!"I,A3!"0-Kb$d5p?M$J$I$KN)$A8~$+$&@o;N$G$"$j!"$"$N0NBg$J!"$3$l$N$_$,??@<$H!"6b%T%+$NGO$7$+$J$$$N$+!"$H!#A4G=$N?@$K$h$C$FB$$i$l$??M4V$N?4$K$D$$$F!"$o$?$7$O$=$&$$$&$b$N$r?.$8$?$/$J$$!#$b$C$H$b4w$^$o$7$$!"?@$rK:$l$?56A1!"F;3Z!";`3$$N$[$H$j$N1n$N2>LL$N2<$K?<$/$+$/$l!"$b$C$H$b$-$?$J$$!"$"$V$i$.$C$?(B$BK:5Q$N@n(B($B%l!<%F(B)$B$NE%$d?eAp$N2<$K$"$k$+$N$h$&$KK:$l$i$l$J$,$i!"$3$N?@$N@$3&$K@8$r$&$1$?$9$Y$F$N?M$S$H$N?4$N$J$+$K!"0MA3$H$7$F?@@-$N$-$i$a$-$,!"$M$`$C$F$$$k$N$G$"$k!#L\$6$a$h!"L4Kb$K$&$J$5$l$FL2$k?M$S$H$h!"L\$6$a$F!"5/$-$h!"$5$b$J$1$l$P1J5W$KBD$A$F$7$^$&$G$"$m$&!*!!$3$l$OF$-$D$/$5$l$F!"0-Kb$N$b$H$XBD$A$F9T$/$N$G$"$k!#$3$&$7$??@@-$,$_$:$+$i$N$&$A$KF0$/$N$r46$8!"$&$J$5$l$?L4$N$J$+$G$=$l$N$+$9$+$J0E<($r$$$/$i$+$G$b46$8$k

Past and Present: Thomas Carlyle, 1843, 
Book 4 Chapter 4: Captains of Industry

The Leaders of Industry, if Industry is ever to be led, are virtually the Captains of the World; if there be no nobleness in them, there will never be an Aristocracy more. But let the Captains of Industry consider: once again, are they born of other clay than the old Captains of Slaughter; doomed forever to be no Chivalry but a mere gold-plated Doggery, - what the French well name Canaille,  'Doggery' with more or less gold carrion at its disposal? Captains of Industry are the true Fighters, henceforth recognisable as the only true ones: Fighters against Chaos, Necessity and the Devils and Jötuns; and lead on Mankind in that great, and alone true, and universal warfare; the stars in their courses fighting for them, and all Heaven and all Earth saying audibly, Well done! Let the Captains of Industry retire into their own hearts, and ask solemnly, if there is nothing but vulturous hunger for fine wines, valet reputation and gilt carriages, discoverable there? Of hearts made by the Almighty God I will not believe such a thing. Deep-hidden under wretchedest god-forgetting Cants, Epicurisms, Dead-Sea Apisms: forgotten as under foulest fat Lethe mud and weeds, there is yet in all hearts born into this God's-World a spark of the Godlike slumbering. Awake, O nightmare sleepers. Awake, arise, or be forever fallen! This is not playhouse poetry; it is sober fact. Our England, our world cannot live as it is. It will connect itself with a God again, or go down with nameless throes and fire-consummation to the Devils. Thou who feelest aught of such a Godlike stirring in thee, any faintest intimation of it as through heavy-laden dreams, follow it, I conjure thee. Arise, save thyself, be one of those that save thy country.



$B!V(BCaptains of Industry $B$NM3Mh(B ($B$a$b$i$s$@$`(B)$B!W(B
$B!X(BBELL$B!Y(BNo.5, [$BN"LL(B] (2007.2.19)

  $B!V%-%c%W%F%s%:!&%*%V!&%$%s%@%9%H%j!e$N9;@'$H$b$_$J$5$l$k%-%c%C%A%U%l!<%:$G$9$,!"=PE5$O!"%$%.%j%9$N;WA[2H!&Nr;K2H(B$B%H!<%^%9!&%+!<%i%$%k(B(Thomas Carlyle 1795-1881)$B$N(B1843$BG/$NCx=q!X2a5n$H8=:_!Y(BPast and present $B$KM3Mh$7$^$9!#F1=q$NBh(B4$BJT!H(BHoroscope$B!I$N(B$BBh(B4$B>O(B$B$O!H(BCaptains of Industry$B!I$HBj$5$l$F$$$^$9!#(B


  
$B!X(B$B>b(B : $B0l66Bg3XImB0?^=q4[Js!Y(BNo.32(1997$BG/(B3$B7n(B) p.6$B$N5W2fB@O:(B$B!H(BTempus fugit$B!I(B$B$K$O!"%h!<%m%C%QN13XCf$N(B1901($BL@<#(B34)$BG/(B2$B7n$K!V>&2JBg3X@_N)%NI,MW!W$HBj$9$k$$$o$f$k!V%Y%k%j%s@k8@!W$r5/Ap$7$F9bEy>&6H3X9;$+$iBg3X$X$N>:3J1?F0$rE83+$7$?K\3X$N(B($BJ!EDFA;0$r4^$`(B)$B$O!V$3$N%9%m!<%,%s$K$$$?$/467c!"5"9q8e!V;:6H$N;XF3&@8$NL\I8$H$7$?$b$N$NG!$/!"$=$l$r$&$1$?3X@8$N\|J8$N%9%m!<%,%s$H$7$F!XF1Ak2q;(;o!Y$KEY!98+$i$l!"<$MhJl9;$K;v$"$k$4$H$K9b>'$5$l<~CN$5$l:#F|$K;j$C$?!#!W!V!X2a5n$H8=:_!Y$K$OB?$/$NHG$,$"$j!"(BPenguin $BHG(B1$B:}$b$N!X%+!<%i%$%kA*=8!Y(B(1967)$B$K$b!X2a5n$H8=:_!Y$OF~$C$F$$$k$,Bh(B4$B4,(B4$B>O$O>JN,$5$l$F$$$k!#!W$H5-$5$l$F$$$^$9!#(B

$B"(ImB0?^=q4[$NB"=q!'(B $B86=q(B Past and present$B!Z(B2330:510$B![$[$+!"K]Lu!X2a5n$H8=:_!Y!Z(BOAe:53:3$B![$[$+(B


$BJ!EDFA;0(B (1874-1930) $BJ88%%j%9%H(B
(1989.12)$B!V(B$BJ!EDFA;0=q;o(B : $B0l664X78$rCf?4$H$7$F(B$B!W6bBt4v;R!X0l66O@AQ!Y(B102(6), p.960-972$B!Z(BZD:71$B![(B

$B6bBt4v;R!V(B$BJ!EDFA;0=q;o(B : $B0l664X78$rCf?4$H$7$F(B$B!W!X0l66O@AQ!Y(B102(6), p.960-972 (1989.12)$B!Z(BZD:71$B![(B

(1901.4.30)$B!V>&2JBg3X@_N)%NI,MW!W@P@n4`!$@P@nJ88c!$?@EDG5Ip!$BmK\H~IW!$DEB<=(>>!$J!EDFA;0(B, $B;VED(B{$B6b9C(B}$BB@O:!$4X0l(B. $B!X9bEy>&6HU\9;U\M'Prp8;o!Y(B15$B9f(B, p.55-62$B!Z(BZA:34$B![(B

$B!X0l66Bg3X3X@);K;qNA!YBh(B2$B4,(B($BBh(B3$B=8(B), p.202-207$B!Z(B082:9:3$B![!Z(BAz:180:2$B![(B

$B$+$_$7$P$$!V0KG=Ci7I$NCO?^:n$j!W(B / $B:n!&?^!'$d$^$A$c$s!"3(!'0KF#5WH~;R!J0KF#5WH~;R%G%6%$%s%k!<%`!K(B($B$*$b$7$mCO?^$HB,NL(B)
$BC^GHBg3XImB0?^=q4[(B  $BJ?@.(B19$BG/EY(B$B4k2hE8(B$B!V8ECO?^$N@$3&(B : $B@$3&?^$H$=$NHGLZ!W(B2007$BG/(B10$B7n(B1$BF|(B($B7n(B)-26$BF|(B($B6b(B) $B5.=E=qE8<(<<(B

$BC^GHBg3XImB0?^=q4[E8<((BBlog


$B$=$l$r$d$i$J$1$l$P!"@8$-$F$$$1$J$$%F!<%^$r$5$,$7$J$5$$(B 2005.12.19
$B%=%&%k%_%e!<%8%C%/!"$=$7$F?N5A$J$-@o$$!"$=$7$F%j%k%1!#(B 2005.12.20
$B%j%k%1(B($B9b0B9q@$Lu(B)$B!X
$B!V(B  
$B$"$J$?$O8f<+J,$N;m$,$$$$$+$I$&$+$r$*?R$M$K$J$k!#$"$J$?$O;d$K$*?R$M$K$J$k!#A0$K$O$[$+$N?M$K$*?R$M$K$J$C$?!#$"$J$?$O;(;o$K;m$r$*Aw$j$K$J$k!#$[$+$N;m$HHf$Y$F$4$i$s$K$J$k!"$=$7$F$I$3$+$NJT=8It$,$"$J$?$N8f;n:n$rJV$7$F$-$?$+$i$H$$$C$F!"<+?.$r$0$i$D$+$;$i$l$k!#$G$O!J;d$KCi8@$r$*5v$72<$5$C$?$o$1$G$9$+$i!K;d$,$*4j$$$7$^$7$g$&!"$=$s$J$3$H$O0l@Z$*$d$a$J$5$$!#$"$J$?$O30$X4c$r8~$1$F$$$i$C$7$c$k!#$@$,2?$h$j$b:#!"$"$J$?$N$J$5$C$F$O$$$1$J$$$3$H$,$=$l$J$N$G$9!#C/$b$"$J$?$K=u8@$7$?$j$B$J$1$l$P$J$i$J$$(B$B$+$H!#?<$$Ez$($r5a$a$F<+8J$NFb$XFb$X$H7!$j2<$2$F$4$i$s$J$5$$!#$=$7$F$b$7$3$NEz$($,9NDjE*$G$"$k$J$i$P!"$b$7$"$J$?$,NO6/$$C1=c$J0l8l!"!V;d$O=q$+$J$1$l$P$J$i$L!W$r$b$C$F!"$"$N??7u$JLd$$$KEz$($k$3$H$,$G$-$k$J$i$P!"$=$N$H$-$O$"$J$?$N@836$r$3$NI,A3$K=>$C$FBG$A$?$F$F2<$5$$!#!W(B(p.14-15)

$B!X0$It6`Li<+EA!YEl5~(B : $B?7D, $B!V0lG/8eGZ$N3X@8$NJs9p$rJ9$-$J$,$i!";d$b%j%k%1$rFI$s$G$_$h$&$H;W$C$?$+$i$G$"$k!#$^$::G=i$K!X$B!V$"$J$?$O8f<+J,$N;m$,$$$$$+$I$&$+$r$*?R$M$K$J$k!#$"$J$?$O;d$K$*?R$M$K$J$k!#A0$K$O$[$+$N?M$K$*?R$M$K$J$C$?!#$"$J$?$O;(;o$K;m$r$*Aw$j$K$J$k!#$[$+$N;m$HHf$Y$F$4$i$s$K$J$k!"$=$7$F$I$3$+$NJT=8It$,$"$J$?$N8f;n:n$rJV$7$F$-$?$+$i$H$$$C$F!"<+?.$r$0$i$D$+$;$i$l$k!#$G$O!J;d$KCi8@$r$*5v$72<$5$C$?$o$1$G$9$+$i!K;d$,$*4j$$$7$^$7$g$&!"$=$s$J$3$H$O0l@Z$*$d$a$J$5$$!#$"$J$?$O30$X4c$r8~$1$F$$$i$C$7$c$k!"$@$,2?$h$j$b:#!"$"$J$?$N$J$5$C$F$O$$$1$J$$$3$H$,$=$l$J$N$G$9!#C/$b$"$J$?$K=u8@$7$?$j$B$J$1$l$P$J$i$J$$(B$B$+$H!#?<$$Ez$($r5a$a$F<+8J$NFb$XFb$X$H7!$j2<$2$F$4$i$s$J$5$$!#$=$7$F$b$7$3$NEz$($,9NDjE*$G$"$k$J$i$P!"$b$7$"$J$?$,NO6/$$C1=c$J0l8l!"!X;d$O=q$+$J$1$l$P$J$i$L!Y$r$b$C$F!"$"$N??7u$JLd$$$KEz$($k$3$H$,$G$-$k$J$i$P!"$=$N$H$-$O$"$J$?$N@836$r$3$NI,A3$K=>$C$FBG$A$?$F$F2<$5$$!#!W!J9b0B9q@$Lu!K!W(B(p.80-81)